Am I missing something here? This is a second run of boards, did you get permission from Don for the first run? if so, why would you need permission for a second run of the same board? On another note, the basic idea and design was Don's, you have modified the design and added other aspects to the circuit, so it is no longer his design, but yours. 90% of the designs in DIY (and in production synth modules) are based on something else, whether it is someone else's circuit, a modification of the app notes for the IC, or a circuit out of the old Electronotes, it doesn't matter, if you make any changes to it, it is now your design, most of my designs are based around the chip manufacturers app notes, or a circuit I found in Electronotes, so according to your logic I should be asking the chip manufacturers for their permission before I get any boards done up, or I should spend years trying to track down the guy who submitted the circuit to Electronotes 30 years ago, sometimes this "Intellectual Property" can be pushed a bit to far. If you want to make a direct clone of a specific module (panels,circuit,pcb) then yes, you should get the original designers permission, otherwise I see no reason for it. My 2 cents worth, Dave
Message
Re: LPG's
2008-12-19 by David Vandenberg
Attachments
- No local attachments were found for this message.