Time for my first serious complaint. There's a global parameter (under the ARP button) to determine whether or not arpeggiators are transmitted to external synths. The problem is that if it is set to "on" then arpeggiator notes are sent out the MIDI port *even if the track is set to internal only*, and if it is set to "off" then arpeggiator notes are NOT sent out the MIDI port, even if the track is set to external only or both. Unless I'm missing something (I am using OS 2.0), this effectively makes the arpeggiators useless for controlling external synths, since my choices are (a) put a synth on MIDI port A but manually turn off any channels that might receive unwanted arp data - not practical live (b) do not put a synth on MIDI port A, rendering it useless, or (c) turn arp transmit off and do not use the arpeggiators to control external synths. None of these is satisfactory. I hope that I am missing something or that there are plans to fix this bug in an update, because otherwise I'm having a hard time seeing this as anything but a very bad design decision. Tracks set to "INT" should not transmit MIDI data at all, tracks set to "EXT" should always transmit MIDI data, and there's an Arp on/off/Preset/Master switch on every track already, which should determine whether or not the arp is transmitted. The global setting should only override the track settings when it is set to "off", as a kind of master kill switch. Has anyone else noticed this? Does it make sense at all for it to work this way? I don't see any provision for "printing" arp output to tracks either, aside from running a cable from output to input or using another sequencer. (While I'm on about it the other settings for keyboard and knob transmission could be a little smarter as well - if the mode is "basic" and the currently active track is assigned to an external synth it would be nice if the keyboard and knobs followed suit. This I can deal with however.)
Message
Arpeggiator out useless?
2003-06-17 by robotchas
Attachments
- No local attachments were found for this message.