Mellotronists group photo

Yahoo Groups archive

Mellotronists

Index last updated: 2026-03-31 23:14 UTC

Thread

Re: [Mellotronists] MKII Pops

Re: [Mellotronists] MKII Pops

2002-11-20 by kenmerb@aol.com

In a message dated 11/20/02 4:19:10 AM Eastern Standard Time, j.k.beresford@... writes:


Show quoted textHide quoted text
I don't know why this should happen only with multiple notes. I
sometimes get a "bump" sound at the beginning of the odd note
and that's crap on the tape. If I clean it just before the heads with
IPA it goes away. Is your pad assembly tightened down properly?
I'm wondering if it's moving when you engage a full chord.


It's definitely not noise or anything on the tape. I've recorded the sound on MP3s, and using wave editing software you can see the random discharge spikes in the audio signal. Right now I have a theory that it's some kind of static discharge taking place along the tapes, between the tape heads and the rear drum. Playing the tapes makes contact between the tape heads and the drum, causing the discharge. Only on bank #1 because there's less tape between the two, making discharge easier. Multiple notes because that provides more paths for the discharge to occur. I'm no electronics expert, just trying to fit the symptoms to a possible cause. Also, it *sounds* like a static discharge. At least one other 'Tron owner has had a similar problem with static discharge (on an M400). However, I'm not sure how to test this theory.

I tried removing the cycling plug from the power pack and I still get the pops, so it's probably not related to the cycling circuitry at all.

You may have a point about the pad assembly - I did have that off, so it's worth checking. Thanks.

Ken M.

Re: [Mellotronists] MKII Pops

2002-11-20 by Rick Blechta

kenmerb@... wrote:

In a message dated 11/20/02 4:19:10 AM Eastern Standard Time, j.k.beresford@... writes:
Ken Merbler wrote:
It's definitely not noise or anything on the tape. I've recorded the sound on MP3s, and using wave editing software you can see the random discharge spikes in the audio signal. Right now I have a theory that it's some kind of static discharge taking place along the tapes, between the tape heads and the rear drum. Playing the tapes makes contact between the tape heads and the drum, causing the discharge. Only on bank #1 because there's less tape between the two, making discharge easier. Multiple notes because that provides more paths for the discharge to occur. I'm no electronics expert, just trying to fit the symptoms to a possible cause. Also, it *sounds* like a static discharge. At least one other 'Tron owner has had a similar problem with static discharge (on an M400). However, I'm not sure how to test this theory.

I tried removing the cycling plug from the power pack and I still get the pops, so it's probably not related to the cycling circuitry at all.

You may have a point about the pad assembly - I did have that off, so it's worth checking. Thanks.

Ken M.

Wow! I think I have the solution! MY tapes (LH keyboard, especially) sometimes have a tendency to audibly "snap", and when I first turn it on, there's a definite "crackle" on certain notes. Ken, you've been reporting "pops". It's my guess that Martinge was eating his breakfast to close to the recording gear when he was making our tapes. You know how he loves those rice crispies...

Rick B.

Surprised that most machines don't hiccup and give off "beery" fumes...

Re: [Mellotronists] MKII Pops

2002-11-20 by kenmerb@aol.com

In a message dated 11/20/02 11:06:26 AM Eastern Standard Time, rick@... writes:


Show quoted textHide quoted text
Wow! I think I have the solution! MY tapes (LH keyboard, especially) sometimes have a tendency to audibly "snap", and when I first turn it on, there's a definite "crackle" on certain notes. Ken, you've been reporting "pops". It's my guess that Martinge was eating his breakfast to close to the recording gear when he was making our tapes. You know how he loves those rice crispies...


OK, Rick, you had me thinking you were serious there for a second.

I also get the snap and crackle out of both speakers when I fire up #247, but it goes away after a few seconds. It makes the same exact sound as my 1962 Fender Pro amp when I turn that on. I attribute this to old age, as these are electronic devices nearing 40 years of age (that's 80+ in human years). It's just their way of saying " I'm old, leave me alone! Where's my hat? "


Speaking of strange noises, KL and I have noticed a strange noise on at least two of the French horn notes, near the beginning of the sounds. You should probably contact me off-list to discuss, otherwise it could be embarrassing. I don't want to describe the sound, other than to ask if, by chance, these were recorded at your "House of Windsor" studio? I *am * serious - there is something strange on a couple of the notes.

Also, has anyone noticed the three-second sound loop which appears to make up the low G note of the Russian choir? It's almost as though the entire Russian choir is trying to mimic the sound of a car starting in Siberia. I'm serious about this one also.

Of course, none of these are nearly as annoying as my popping MKII .

All together now!
( as sung to the tune of "The Twelve Days of Christmas")

*On the third day of Christmas, Martin sold to me

* A Russian choir looping,
* Two French horns farting,
* and my MKII's still popping at me!

Ken M

Re: [Mellotronists] MKII Pops

2002-11-21 by Rick Blechta

kenmerb@... wrote:


Speaking of strange noises, KL and I have noticed a strange noise on at least two of the French horn notes, near the beginning of the sounds. You should probably contact me off-list to discuss, otherwise it could be embarrassing. I don't want to describe the sound, other than to ask if, by chance, these were recorded at your "House of Windsor" studio? I *am * serious - there is something strange on a couple of the notes.


Ken,

I am tempted to give a flip answer here (but I PROMISED not to make any more jokes at Mike Dickson's expense, that I would NEVER AGAIN mention on this list what he suffers from.), but I suspect that you're not hearing the results of incomplete digestion but something more insidious to those who try to record 35 perfect notes in something other than a hermetically sealed recording studio: ambient noise, in this case, more specifically, traffic noises.

When we recorded this sound, the piccolo and the bass clarinet, the flight pattern for the airport seems to have been somewhat nearer to my house than usual and we seemed to have a rash of cars and trucks desperately in need of mechanical care. Did I mention fire trucks? There were not one, but two fires in the nearby apartment buildings on that fateful night!

Merinque Smith had the unenviable task of sorting through all the takes (some notes with as many as ten) for to try to find ones that didn't have any "outside influences" and also sounded good and were in tune (a minor qualification), and I think he did a damn fine job. But he has the masters. What's the word, old chap?

I will fire up old Brenda (as soon as I put in a good supply of coal) and check out your claims. What notes are you speaking of specifically?

However, I was just thinking... When the final takes of the master tapes were being put together, Dickson was present at the Streetly World Headquarters in Lower-Upper Blithbury (hard upon the Twat & Handbag Pub) in order to make the demo tapes for the Streetly Library Website. No. It couldn't be. It's just too far fetched to be true...

And for Gene's earlier e-mail, I agree that listening to the outtakes would be quite illuminating as well as very funny. For example, when we were recording the bass flute recently, my red-headed better half suddenly stopped playing and said, "Oh f___! Now I've got the hiccups!" I (being the time keeper and present in the vocal booth with her) unwisely said, "Oh, then we can just record some shorter notes between the hiccups." She called me a seven-letter word that begins with "A" and then very sweetly said, "Oh! Is the tape still running?"

My feeling is we should leave the exchange in, in place of the 35th note, but then I'd probably be sleeping on the sofa the rest of my farking life.

Hope this sorts everything out.

Rick

Re: [Mellotronists] MKII Pops

2002-11-21 by kenmerb@aol.com

In a message dated 11/20/02 7:54:03 PM Eastern Standard Time, rick@... writes:


Show quoted textHide quoted text
will fire up old Brenda (as soon as I put in a good supply of coal) and check out your claims. What notes are you speaking of specifically?


Rick,

After listening to the French horns again tonight, there seem to be three bad notes, but I'm pretty sure it's a tape related problem and nothing to do with your performance. The question is, where did the problem occur - the master tapes, the copy made for my set, or the installation of my set. Or, somewhere else? The notes are numbers 20, 22 & 25 on the French horns. I'll bet your set is fine.


The Russian choir on note #1 definitely sounds like a tape loop to KL and I.

I'm trying to load a page containing MP3s of all the sounds in question (along with examples of the "pops"). I'll let you know when they're out there.

Ken M

Re: MKII Pops

2002-11-22 by dandc74

Ken,

Though not a 'tron owner yet (#574 is still waiting for me to deliver
it from it's purple roadcase with the degenerating blue foam), those
pops sound like static pops to me. Having worked for years with
larger reel-to-reel machines, it reminds me of when the static drains
on the hub platters of Scully 280's would stop making good ground
contact followed by the static buildup from fast winding a tape
finding it's way to ground resulting in a pop or pops in the dub.
Funny how it never seemed to be able to find a ground while the tape
was motionless, it always waited to discharge after the tape has
been in motion for a moment or two. After several
speaker-cone-shredding snaps, things would settle down while one
rewound the tape to start the dub over again. And again, as soon as
the tape was played back, the pops would re-occur in about the same
places, but once the hub drains were renewed, then the popping
ceased. Were any provisions made for this on the Mark II or was it
calculated that the numerous points of contact the tape makes as it
winds through the 'tron would provide plenty of grounding
opportunities?

Just a thought....

FS. Weller

Re: [Mellotronists] Re: MKII Pops

2002-11-22 by kenmerb@aol.com

In a message dated 11/21/2002 7:40:31 PM Eastern Standard Time, capt_carbonarc@... writes:


Show quoted textHide quoted text
After several
speaker-cone-shredding snaps, things would settle down while one
rewound the tape to start the dub over again. And again, as soon as
the tape was played back, the pops would re-occur in about the same
places, but once the hub drains were renewed, then the popping
ceased. Were any provisions made for this on the Mark II or was it
calculated that the numerous points of contact the tape makes as it
winds through the 'tron would provide plenty of grounding
opportunities?


I think that the main argument against the static discharge theory is that once discharged (via the "pops") that the problem would go away. However, your experience with recharging the static by rewinding the tape intrigues me. Could explain a lot. I wonder what area of the MKII would function as the "hub drain"? I know that Bob Young appears to have a ground wire on his MKII which is not on mine. I think that JB's leaning away from the static discharge idea, but that's what it seems like to me. However, he's got a lot more experience with these things than I do, so it could be something completely different.

Thanks for your input - I learn a little more with each message like this. That's why I put the MP3s out there.

Ken M.

Re: MKII Pops

2002-11-22 by dandc74

>>That's why I put the MP3s out there.>>

Ken,

And I appreciate those MP3s that you've put out there.....since that
is the closest I'm getting to #574 for the time being! =)

FS. Weller

Re: [Mellotronists] MKII Pops

2002-11-22 by kenmerb@aol.com

In a message dated 11/21/02 10:40:45 PM Eastern Standard Time, rick@... writes:


Show quoted textHide quoted text
Well, Ken, I listened to them all, and I don't have an answer. With the McDonald flute, the MkII flute and my French Horn, there are no pops or dropouts--at least on my mellotron. I can only speak for the French horn, but I certainly couldn't do something like that while playing and I know it didn't go down on the DAT like that. I've also heard the master tapes for Ian's recording and it is brilliant


Rick,

Just to clarify here, I don't have a problem with any of the flute recordings.

There are two types of sound problems I'm noticing. The first type (and primary one for me) are the pops. These aren't actually recorded on the tapes, there's just some kind of discharge taking place within my MKII which is all over the audio on bank #1 only. So, it's specific to my machine.

The second type of problem *is* recorded on my tapes, and affects the French horns ( it's not your playing, more like audio dropouts on three notes ) and the single Russian choir note ( looping-type sound ). There's nothing I can do about these now, so I just wanted to report them.

Ken M.