2001-09-26 by mh@toomanyartists.com
... okay, you forced me to get nit-picky and state why you didn t answer the question. He stated a case if you have a film with a DR which is small enough
Thread view
Attachments: 0
2001-09-26 by Todd Flashner
... Mike, Honestly, I m on the edge. I feel a little more info and I ll get this securely, a little more confusion and I ll loose it completely. Would you run
Thread view
Attachments: 0
2001-09-26 by Johnny Deadman
... not true, Austin -- John Brownlow http://www.pinkheadedbug.com
Thread view
Attachments: 0
2001-09-26 by mh@toomanyartists.com
... That isn t true, Todd just mentioned a case of thinking that a 14bit scanner did this when in fact it doesn t but he would like it too (I assume). I think
Thread view
Attachments: 0
2001-09-26 by mh@toomanyartists.com
... okay, you re alot further off than I thought you were. You need to read more carefully or something. I was talking about expanding the entire range the
Thread view
Attachments: 0
2001-09-26 by Austin Franklin
... For raw data, yes...but of what use, I still don t know. ... Yes it does. That s like saying two apples are a different two than two oranges! ... But a
Thread view
Attachments: 0
2001-09-26 by Austin Franklin
... Sure I did. I gave an explanation for an answer. I ve tried the yes/no answers with you two, and you always come back and ask why , so I guess I can t
Thread view
Attachments: 0
2001-09-26 by Austin Franklin
... This is getting futile. Yes you COULD do this, but for most everyone it is entirely useless. No one but you seems to have any desire to want to do it.
Thread view
Attachments: 0
2001-09-26 by Austin Franklin
... It has a higher density range than B&W negatives.
Thread view
Attachments: 0
2001-09-26 by Austin Franklin
... Yes there is, it s an operation, and you re asking the scanner to decide what valid image data is. That s non-optimal. ... WRONG. How do you know that
Thread view
Attachments: 0
2001-09-26 by mh@toomanyartists.com
... yes, what was Austin talking about, color neg has a higher density range than what? Todd, did you get what I was saying about 10 vs 14 bit in the other
Thread view
Attachments: 0
2001-09-26 by Todd Flashner
... Ya me too. :-) I thought due to it s low density dye clouds color neg film was of low density range, thus low Dynamic Range, thus an easy scan. Don t tell
Thread view
Attachments: 0
2001-09-26 by mh@toomanyartists.com
... Could you tell us about these? Which ones are the toned ones? maybe a little about what papers were used, etc... thanks, mikeH
Thread view
Attachments: 0
2001-09-26 by mh@toomanyartists.com
... What does the human eye have to do with it if you are expanding a small tonal region to use a larger gamut that the human eye CAN see? -mh
Thread view
Attachments: 0
2001-09-26 by mh@toomanyartists.com
... yes, I too have no experience with Minolta scanners and am saying nothing good or bad about them in this thread. -mikeH
Thread view
Attachments: 0
2001-09-26 by mh@toomanyartists.com
... except you didn t answer is question, hehe The answer is no.
Thread view
Attachments: 0
2001-09-26 by mh@toomanyartists.com
... There is nothing not optimal about it, it doesn t hurt the data in any way. ... YOUR histograms start out compressed (with a raw scan) Im not talking about
Thread view
Attachments: 0
2001-09-26 by Austin Franklin
... All that you and I can see. ... I suggest you do some research on the capabilities of the human eye...
Thread view
Attachments: 0
2001-09-26 by Austin Franklin
... Well, I don t know about all that...but some of their technical statements were not really accurate, their example of 14 bits vs 16 bits wasn t using real
Thread view
Attachments: 0
2001-09-26 by mh@toomanyartists.com
... Are you saying that todays scanners capture all the tones in any given negative or chrome, as long as their density is not out of the scanners range?
Thread view
Attachments: 0
2001-09-26 by Austin Franklin
... Color negative film has a higher dynamic range, and therefore will occupy a wider range of values...you get more tones, but it s not from intermediate
Thread view
Attachments: 0
2001-09-26 by Austin Franklin
... You are right, but only if the data is low bit justified.
Thread view
Attachments: 0
2001-09-26 by Austin Franklin
... WHY spread it out? Why have the scanner do something you may not want it to do, or do it not optimally? For 8 bit data, this is done...but you have to
Thread view
Attachments: 0
2001-09-26 by Todd Flashner
... Isn t that the case if you have a film with a DR which is small enough that it can be captured by a 10-bit scanner, but you scan it with a 14-bit scanner?
Thread view
Attachments: 0
2001-09-26 by mh@toomanyartists.com
... A 14bit scanner captures (maps you could say) to a larger piece of the 16bit histogram than the 10bit. But at the same time it captures more dense negs. So
Thread view
Attachments: 0
2001-09-26 by Austin Franklin
... Unless you re scanning for another species, they are completely useless, and you will never see them in a final image that contains all the range of tones
Thread view
Attachments: 0
2001-09-26 by Todd Flashner
... Come again please? I don t get this. They should look the same BECAUSE the 14 bit scanner is capable of capturing more dense negs? Todd
Thread view
Attachments: 0
2001-09-26 by mh@toomanyartists.com
... I would go crazy with the tones! i would love them and feed them and keep them forever and ever!
Thread view
Attachments: 0
2001-09-26 by mh@toomanyartists.com
... This isn t an issue for me, but it has to do with the original question. Which is why, if you are scanning something with a range of 3.7 on a scanner only
Thread view
Attachments: 0
2001-09-26 by Todd Flashner
... I know I for one await *your* answer (Austin) with baited breath. If you can explain this clearly, and why the difference yields differing spans, we will
Thread view
Attachments: 0
2001-09-26 by Todd Flashner
... I know, I m dying. If this goes on much longer my business, health, and sex life will suffer --more! ;-) I just hate that I haven t gotten to the Ah-ha!
Thread view
Attachments: 0
2001-09-26 by Peter
Wow, there is a whole lot of techno babble laced, pompous opinions about a device that apparently no one has used! To read the opinions that are expressed in
Thread view
Attachments: 0
2001-09-26 by Austin Franklin
... That is correct. There are two possible places of bunching . One, in the actual span of the data in the actual scanner dynamic range (bit depth), and
Thread view
Attachments: 0
2001-09-26 by mh@toomanyartists.com
... What Todd should have said is in linear fashion, not GAMMA (that threw Austin for a loop) What Austin should have said at the end there is; data is bunched
Thread view
Attachments: 0
2001-09-26 by Austin Franklin
... It matters in how much space the values will occupy in the 16 bit space when you get them from the scanner. If the values are low bit justified, they will
Thread view
Attachments: 0
2001-09-26 by Austin Franklin
... Any time the data is manipulated it is NOT raw, plain and simple. Spreading it out makes it NOT raw data. That was the only point. I don t understand
Thread view
Attachments: 0
2001-09-26 by mh@toomanyartists.com
... I don t disagree, but if the scanner is ONLY capable of capturing that range and nothing outside of it, it seems to me that it should, maybe even as a
Thread view
Attachments: 0
2001-09-26 by mh@toomanyartists.com
... They could probably be found on the internet somewhere. I m sure they are pretty bad. I don t think they rated dynamic range for them back then. ... I ask
Thread view
Attachments: 0
2001-09-26 by Austin Franklin
... I agree ;-)
Thread view
Attachments: 0
2001-09-26 by Todd Flashner
... I believe some scanners can do this, like the Imacon for one, but I don t consider that a raw scan anymore. That s a manipulated scan. Todd
Thread view
Attachments: 0
2001-09-26 by Todd Flashner
Austin, In another post I accused you of contradicting yourself. I should give you the opportunity to defend yourself. I think you do understand this stuff, so
Thread view
Attachments: 0
2001-09-26 by ternahan
here you go... t ternahan@gentlelens.net You are invited to visit: http://www.photo.net/photodb/folder?folder_id=150137
Thread view
Attachments: 0
2001-09-26 by mh@toomanyartists.com
... What difference does it make? I was answering his question of why the raw scan doesn t fill the whole 16bit space. Luckily, we don t have to worry about
Thread view
Attachments: 0
2001-09-26 by Austin Franklin
... Do you believe it is high bit justified, or just left low bit justified? In other words, does the scanner A/D give you a 12 bit value of 0101 1010 1010.
Thread view
Attachments: 0
2001-09-26 by Austin Franklin
... OK. ... Got the specs for them? ... Because that s what ratio values typically are. Ratios are relative to 1. You set 1 to some density value, and when
Thread view
Attachments: 0
2001-09-26 by Austin Franklin
I don t doubt that. It could be better CCD, better analog front end, better A/D...basically, better linearity, better noise, better optics...better transport.
Thread view
Attachments: 0
2001-09-26 by Austin Franklin
... What theoretical arguments ? I m talking reality. ... It doesn t, but it s designed TO be that way. It is easier TO design it to be this way. What
Thread view
Attachments: 0
2001-09-26 by mh@toomanyartists.com
... Simple answer; because you are scanning into a 16bit space and the scanner is not 16bits. That 3.7 worth of information is linearly placed along the 16bit
Thread view
Attachments: 0
2001-09-26 by mh@toomanyartists.com
... okay, well why don t you make a CCD with more volts and less noise? You can t put aside our theoretical arguments by saying a CCD has noise. ... Why does
Thread view
Attachments: 0
2001-09-26 by mh@toomanyartists.com
... Never mind about that, I guess when you said the way current scanners are designed you were correct. ... I don t know about 3.2 drange, but how about the
Thread view
Attachments: 0