50g group photo

Yahoo Groups archive

50g

Archive for 50g.

Index last updated: 2026-03-30 00:59 UTC

Thread

time for a change

time for a change

2008-07-22 by Fatih Can

guys
i've been reading all correspondence with joy and benefiting a lot...
having read the recent ones on ergonomics, connectivity of the machine don't you think that we, who spent at least 2-3 hrs a day with calculators, deserve better resolutions, colors and video quality?
who would HP not consider to develop calcs that have the same features that we see in the PDAs of HP or any mobile phone nowadays?
simply why should we care to change AAAs -by the way HP50g is a good eater- but recharge our calcs as we do our phones?
fatih

Re: [50g] time for a change

2008-07-22 by Guy Teague

you raise a great point faith. one has only to look at the monstrosity that is the new ti nspire keyboard to see the main problem--the input method. you can buy a $99 palm pilot that has stylus input, why do our calculators not have that simple method of user input which would solve 85% of the ugly keyboard and alpha-mode problems that make me wince in advance each time i reach for a cas calculator knowing i'm going to have to input text.

it makes you wonder what we're actually paying for? the programming of the chips that was basically done 20 or 30 years ago? i would gladly pay triple the price of the most expensive hp or ti model to have just a usable, not a brilliant, just a usable input method and and output i can actually read with squinting or going to another room where the light is better. we should be able to have calculators every bit as sleek and serviceable as ipods or pda or, at the absolute minimum, cell phones.

admit it, we are stuck in the stone age and no one seems to want to be innovative and only stack features on top of a structure that no longer will support those features.

/guy

On Tue, Jul 22, 2008 at 5:07 AM, Fatih Can <f_can2003@...> wrote:
guys
i've been reading all correspondence with joy and benefiting a lot...
having read the recent ones on ergonomics, connectivity of the machine don't you think that we, who spent at least 2-3 hrs a day with calculators, deserve better resolutions, colors and video quality?
who would HP not consider to develop calcs that have the same features that we see in the PDAs of HP or any mobile phone nowadays?
simply why should we care to change AAAs -by the way HP50g is a good eater- but recharge our calcs as we do our phones?
fatih


Re: time for a change

2008-07-22 by George

Hi everyone,

I always liked the latest. I have both the TI NSpire and the HP50G.

I suggest that you buy a TI NSpire before you knock it. Do yourself a
favor if you like/use calculators that much.

The keyboard on the 50g has far more on it's keyboard than the
NSpire.

NSpire's alpha characters are separate and easier to document the
problem in it's note psd screen. Much easier than finding alpha
characters on th HP.

Screen is better on the NSpire and the keyboard is logical which
translates into easy to use.

I personally won't sell either of my two flagship calcs.

NIMH (NIckel Metal Hyride) rechargables?

Be sure to save your work frequently.

George

--- In 50g@yahoogroups.com, Fatih Can <f_can2003@...> wrote:
>
> guys
> i've been reading all correspondence with joy and benefiting a
lot...
> having read the recent ones on ergonomics, connectivity of the
machine don't you think that we, who spent at least 2-3 hrs a day
with calculators, deserve better resolutions, colors and video
quality?
> who would HP not consider to develop calcs that have the same
features that we see in the PDAs of HP or any mobile phone nowadays?
> simply why should we care to change AAAs -by the way HP50g is a
good eater- but recharge our calcs as we do our phones?
> fatih
>

Re: time for a change

2008-07-22 by martin cohen

Look at the Casio Classpad 300/310. It uses a stylus.

Might be what you want.

Re: [50g] Re: time for a change

2008-07-23 by Guy Teague

now that was a great tip! and they even have a mac version.

i've downloaded the trial and i'll install it tomorrow when i get back home to my mac.

/guy

On Tue, Jul 22, 2008 at 7:27 PM, George <gfenisey@...> wrote:
Looks interesting. There is a Classpad 330 according to their web-site.

Try the free download trial of NSpire computer software instead of a
hand held device. Has the best of everything. Great screen, mouse
control, storage capacity. This way you can try a NSpire for 30 days
free. Then buy a device if you like it.

George



Re: [50g] Re: time for a change

2008-07-23 by Guy Teague

this is not promising at all. i've worked in computers and software and calculators for nearly 40 years and i cannot get the ti nspire computer program to give me the answer to 355/113. or indeed the answer to anything at all. i have the calculator keyboard on the screen but the keys don't work. i typed the figures into a box using the mac keyboard.

to say that this software is not intuitive is understating the situation by several orders of magnitude.

yet, in an enormous leap of cognitive dissonance, i also state that i have ordered the calculator. hopefully it will be somewhat easier to use than the computer program, but, given the hp50 and the ti89 as examples, i'm not at all hopeful.

/guy

On Tue, Jul 22, 2008 at 7:43 PM, Guy Teague <gt@...> wrote:
now that was a great tip! and they even have a mac version.

i've downloaded the trial and i'll install it tomorrow when i get back home to my mac.

/guy


On Tue, Jul 22, 2008 at 7:27 PM, George <gfenisey@...> wrote:
Looks interesting. There is a Classpad 330 according to their web-site.

Try the free download trial of NSpire computer software instead of a
hand held device. Has the best of everything. Great screen, mouse
control, storage capacity. This way you can try a NSpire for 30 days
free. Then buy a device if you like it.

George




Re: [50g] Re: time for a change

2008-07-24 by Daniel Stripes

On Wednesday 23 July 2008 07:43:31 Guy Teague wrote:

> yet, in an enormous leap of cognitive dissonance, i also state that i have
> ordered the calculator.

As another owner of hp50g, hp49g+, hp49g, hp28s, hp12c, hp11c, TI-89ti, TI-89,
TI-86, TI-58, and at least a couple others I can't recall at the moment, I
anxiously await your commentary and/or review of the TI-Nspire. Did you order
the CAS version?

Re: [50g] Re: time for a change

2008-07-24 by Guy Teague

yes, i definitely ordered the cas version. 

like you it seems, i've owned nearly every major calculator release from the two major players. not that i need them for anything but to follow along in science books and to satisfy my curiosity. i think i have a ti83/84/89 and hp35s/48/50 and some sort of worthless casio lying around along with a few of the much older hp's.

 as i said, i still consider the hp 27s one of my all time favorites. it was a strange mixed bag of timers and clock, business and statistics and tech and conversion functions. it was for a technical manager and didn't even use rpn. but the display was horrible and the battery life was worse. and the clock was to laugh at--a sundial was more accurate. i guess it just goes to show how individual the liking of one keyboard or input method.

i haven't had time today to return to the mac version of the ti cas software. when i spend 10 minutes and can't do a simple arithmetic operation though i have to wonder if the programmers even gave it to a single person outside the lab to test. at least it's a free trial and perhaps once (or if) i learn the calculator it will become apparent how to run the computer software.

/guy

On Wed, Jul 23, 2008 at 9:55 PM, Daniel Stripes <analogtek@...> wrote:
On Wednesday 23 July 2008 07:43:31 Guy Teague wrote:

> yet, in an enormous leap of cognitive dissonance, i also state that i have
> ordered the calculator.

As another owner of hp50g, hp49g+, hp49g, hp28s, hp12c, hp11c, TI-89ti, TI-89,
TI-86, TI-58, and at least a couple others I can't recall at the moment, I
anxiously await your commentary and/or review of the TI-Nspire.  Did you order
the CAS version?


Re: [50g] Re: time for a change

2008-07-26 by Guy Teague

so someone who owns this calc please take pity on me and tell me how to isolate a symbolic variable. for the simplest of examples, i need to solve for, or isolate 'c' onto one side of this equation.

a+b/c=d

or a+b/c=0

or a+b/c

i've tried all three of these forms and used 'factor', 'solve', and 'expand' with no luck. i've tried some of the forms that have worked on other calculators such as:

a+b/c,c
a+b/c;c
a+b/c:c
a+b/c c

or

a+b/c <enter>
c <enter>

and i've at least skimmed through the users guides and the ref guides for both the calc and for the cas mac software and have not yet found an example nor the forms or paramters for these functions.

thanks,

/guy


On Thu, Jul 24, 2008 at 6:25 PM, Guy Teague <gt@...> wrote:
rec'd calc (cas vers) this afternoon and immediately ran into problems with the computer software. i had installed the mac cas software already and i figured that it would contain the ability to link to the calculator when i got it. wrong. you have to specifically and separately install ti-link software to do that. how is that even logical that their computer software which emulates the calculator won't even link to the calculator? i can't fathom that choice.

at any rate, i installed the ti-link application and although it immediately found the calculator, it failed everything i tried to do: firmware update and backup. it was obviously a permissions error since it kept telling me it couldn't write to the folder it supposedly created to hold its documents: ~/Documents/TI-Nspire/.

of course i went to the top level of that folder and gave it 'r/w = all' permissions and extended those attributes to all enclosed folders. but this still did not fix the problem. then i had an epiphany--perhaps the cas software had created the folder and the link software couldn't use it, improbable as that sounds since ti wrote both of them, so i uninstalled the cas software, deleted the ti-nspire folder, restarted (for luck more than anything else), then installed the link software first. this time it created a different structure inside that folder and the firmware update and the backup both worked. then i re-installed the cas software and it just used the folder the link software had created without a whimper.

g3333sh!! how incompetent can ti mac programmers be in one of their applications can't even use a folder that another of their applications created? and why can't they build a link module into their $120 cas program and integrate the calculator into the software rather than forcing the user to run two different programs?

so i still haven't gotten around to more than the barest touch of the actual calculator. i did find it will not calculate 355/113 unless i hit 'cntl + enter' although it will calculate 2+3 with the enter key. at first i thought of the switch in the hp that will display symbolic or real results, but so far i haven't found something similar in the ti yet, but, as i said, i haven't yet read a single page of documentation.

btw, the display, though it has pretty characters, is not good. it doesn't have any crispness or contrast adjustment that will make it look good. i admit i haven't tried alternate fonts. the keyboard, although it has the 'wobbly keys' syndrome common to   most ti calcs, is surprisingly easier to use than it looks in the pictures. in fact the calc looks much better in person than in the pictures. it is not as large as i feared and feels solid in construction--it nearly feels industrial rather than consumer. it has a sliding cover which stores underneath and it uses those damm 'aaa' batteries which so many manufacturers seem to have entered into a devli/radio shack conspiracy to use since there's no better way to sell a bunch of batteries than to keep consumers from using 'aa's! oh, and one smart design decision was to use a bog standard usb cable to connect to the computer.

more later ...

/guy

Re: time for a change

2008-07-26 by tedwingate

'a+b/c=d'
'c'
ISOL

c=-b/(a-d) will be returned on the stack

Is that the type of thing you're looking for?

Re: [50g] Re: time for a change

2008-07-26 by Guy Teague

i finally figured it out from an error message.

i put in 'solve(a+b/c),c' and it told me that 'a+b/c' wasn't an equation. so i entered:

'solve(a+b/c=0,c)' and bob's your uncle!! i found that:

'solve(a+b/c=d,c)' also works.

so, only two days to figure out that simple item. and i did that without being able to figure out how to edit an entry, so i had to reenter the whole equation each time. and i still haven't figured out how to drag and drop although the cursor turns to a hand.

y'know, why is all this crap so difficult? i'm getting too old to devote a year of my life to learning a non-intuitive calculator.

i did figure out how to do a temperature conversion and it's just as convoluted as the hp50 way--you have to go back and forth into a menu about 4 times unless you want to figure out how to type in the 'degree' symbol i guess. and so far there's no sight of the hundred+ flags of the hp50 nor an equation library. there are 'activities' to download, but i find very few of them useful without opening both their accompanying word and pdf files anyway, so why even bother with the calculator? just download the pdfs.

the templates section looks interesting and i will gradually sneak up on those as i go along. but they are represented as tiny icons, not text--and no little text balloon pops up to tell you what the templates are for.

/guy

On Fri, Jul 25, 2008 at 8:48 PM, Guy Teague <gt@...> wrote:
yeah, that's exactly what i'm looking for.

that's the hp way. but i can't find a similar structure on the nspire cas.

/guy


On Fri, Jul 25, 2008 at 8:37 PM, tedwingate <tedwingate@...> wrote:
'a+b/c=d'
'c'
ISOL

c=-b/(a-d) will be returned on the stack

Is that the type of thing you're looking for?


------------------------------------

Yahoo! Groups Links

<*> To visit your group on the web, go to:
   http://groups.yahoo.com/group/50g/

<*> Your email settings:
   Individual Email | Traditional

<*> To change settings online go to:
   http://groups.yahoo.com/group/50g/join
   (Yahoo! ID required)

<*> To change settings via email:
   mailto:50g-digest@yahoogroups.com
   mailto:50g-fullfeatured@yahoogroups.com

<*> To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:
   50g-unsubscribe@yahoogroups.com

<*> Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to:
   http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/



Re: [50g] Re: time for a change

2008-07-26 by Guy Teague

and now that i've blasted this thing so bad, i find the programming exceptionally easy to use. i was able to write a program that simulated a die toss in 3 lines and less than 3 minutes. i've starred my input, the other lines were pre-filled in:

Define dice()=
Prgm
*Local d
*randInt(1,6) -> d
*Disp d
EndPrgm

the program words were inserted from the catalog, all i supplied was the variable name and the parameters. and running it is as simple as hitting the 'var' key and selecting from a list. the program editor has a nice split-screen mode.

if you guys are getting tired of my little mini-rants and reviews of this calc (seeing as how we are, after all, on an hp50 list) just let me know. but i think many or perhaps most of us have multiple calculators and are interested in all the brands and models.

for those interested i found the following site has some extremely helpful videos of many ti-nspire procedures and their coin toss programming example was extremely easy for me to modify for this dice toss program:

http://movies.atomiclearning.com/k12/ti_nspire/

/guy

On Sat, Jul 26, 2008 at 1:04 AM, Guy Teague <gt@...> wrote:
i finally figured it out from an error message.

i put in 'solve(a+b/c),c' and it told me that 'a+b/c' wasn't an equation. so i entered:

'solve(a+b/c=0,c)' and bob's your uncle!! i found that:

'solve(a+b/c=d,c)' also works.

so, only two days to figure out that simple item. and i did that without being able to figure out how to edit an entry, so i had to reenter the whole equation each time. and i still haven't figured out how to drag and drop although the cursor turns to a hand.

y'know, why is all this crap so difficult? i'm getting too old to devote a year of my life to learning a non-intuitive calculator.

i did figure out how to do a temperature conversion and it's just as convoluted as the hp50 way--you have to go back and forth into a menu about 4 times unless you want to figure out how to type in the 'degree' symbol i guess. and so far there's no sight of the hundred+ flags of the hp50 nor an equation library. there are 'activities' to download, but i find very few of them useful without opening both their accompanying word and pdf files anyway, so why even bother with the calculator? just download the pdfs.

the templates section looks interesting and i will gradually sneak up on those as i go along. but they are represented as tiny icons, not text--and no little text balloon pops up to tell you what the templates are for.

/guy


On Fri, Jul 25, 2008 at 8:48 PM, Guy Teague <gt@...> wrote:
yeah, that's exactly what i'm looking for.

that's the hp way. but i can't find a similar structure on the nspire cas.

/guy


On Fri, Jul 25, 2008 at 8:37 PM, tedwingate <tedwingate@...> wrote:
'a+b/c=d'
'c'
ISOL

c=-b/(a-d) will be returned on the stack

Is that the type of thing you're looking for?


------------------------------------

Yahoo! Groups Links

<*> To visit your group on the web, go to:
   http://groups.yahoo.com/group/50g/

<*> Your email settings:
   Individual Email | Traditional

<*> To change settings online go to:
   http://groups.yahoo.com/group/50g/join
   (Yahoo! ID required)

<*> To change settings via email:
   mailto:50g-digest@yahoogroups.com
   mailto:50g-fullfeatured@yahoogroups.com

<*> To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:
   50g-unsubscribe@yahoogroups.com

<*> Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to:
   http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/




Re: time for a change

2008-07-26 by arthurford4142

I too had waited for OS X version. It was delivered 2 days ago, but
then I got really lucky as my family came down to visit. Haven't even
had time to DL the software. After they leave, I'll be referring back
to your posts. Thanks for sharing.

--- In 50g@yahoogroups.com, "Guy Teague" <accts@...> wrote:
>
> and now that i've blasted this thing so bad, i find the programming

Re: time for a change

2008-07-27 by George

Hi Guy,

Sorry for getting you started.

BUT, I am listening to every word that you and the others are saying.

I didn't get the NSpire CAS version. What is your thought on the
readability of the screen compared to everything else?

My NSpire without CAS says politely the Solve function is not supported
and I need to have a CAS version of course. TI 92 Plus did the Solve
using exactly same syntax you used on the NSpire. The TI 92 screen is
very poor compared to HP calculators in general.

You haven't mentioned the templates yet.

Listening,

George

Re: [50g] Re: time for a change

2008-07-27 by Guy Teague

george, on that website i quote that has the movie tutorials, one of the movies marked 'new' and 'cas' says that the non-cas has solve, but that it can't solve for multiple 0s or something like that.

the screen is just ok. in good light. i would say it's a tiny fraction better than the ti89 and the main reason i don't use the 89 much is because the screen is pretty bad. i have bad eyes, but ... the fonts are better on the nspire and it is more readable, but trying to increase the contrast only darkens the background.

the notes application has just a couple of templates, but they are useful and easy to use, as is the notes application itself. there are about 12-18 math templates, but i haven't tried them much yet, mainly because in all but one of the views i can't tell what the tiny icons represent. i found one view once which had them titled, but i've forgotten where i found it.

i must say i'm beginning to warm up to it somewhat after the initial bad impression. the keyboard with those little nubs sticking up for alpha keys works and i rarely hit double characters. the menu system is convoluted and for a beginner i keep going into the wrong menu system--there are essentially three available most of the time, a couple fixed and one contextual. but i'm already finding myself memorizing sequences such as 'ctl + menu + 5 + 5' or something like that.

it badly needs engineering formulas like the hp48/50 and easier conversions. the nice part is that the programming seems so easy hopefully someone will write stuff like that for it. it only has 20mb of memory, but most everything can be dumped off via the ti-link app. i've got all the available 'activities' (tutorial-like modules) installed and the book 'flatland' and i'm using less than 1/3rd the memory.

as i mentioned earlier, i still can't figure out why the cas computer app won't link to the handheld, but you can develop on either the mac or windows cas app and then move your file to the link program and then move it to the calculator.

/guy



On Sat, Jul 26, 2008 at 10:33 PM, George <gfenisey@...> wrote:
Hi Guy,

Sorry for getting you started.

BUT, I am listening to every word that you and the others are saying.

I didn't get the NSpire CAS version. What is your thought on the
readability of the screen compared to everything else?

My NSpire without CAS says politely the Solve function is not supported
and I need to have a CAS version of course.  TI 92 Plus did the Solve
using exactly same syntax you used on the NSpire. The TI 92 screen is
very poor compared to HP calculators in general.

You haven't mentioned the templates yet.

Listening,

George



------------------------------------

Yahoo! Groups Links

<*> To visit your group on the web, go to:
   http://groups.yahoo.com/group/50g/

<*> Your email settings:
   Individual Email | Traditional

<*> To change settings online go to:
   http://groups.yahoo.com/group/50g/join
   (Yahoo! ID required)

<*> To change settings via email:
   mailto:50g-digest@yahoogroups.com
   mailto:50g-fullfeatured@yahoogroups.com

<*> To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:
   50g-unsubscribe@yahoogroups.com

<*> Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to:
   http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/


Re: time for a change

2008-07-28 by arthurford4142

> My NSpire without CAS says politely the Solve function is not supported

The example equation was 2x^2-5x+2=0. Solve gave the answers of 1/2, 2.
nSolve on both CAS and non-CAS versions give just 0.5, not the second
answer.

Re: time for a change

2008-07-28 by arthurford4142

--- In 50g@yahoogroups.com, "arthurford4142" <arthurford4142@...> wrote:

> The example equation was 2x^2-5x+2=0. Solve gave the answers of 1/2, 2.
> nSolve on both CAS and non-CAS versions give just 0.5, not the second
> answer.

Oops
nSolve(2x^2-5x+2=0,x=1.5) does give the correct second answer of 2. I
was first incorrectly trying to get the second answer with constraints
rather than "guess" as is shown on the bottom syntax line when nSolve
is highlighted in the Catalog.

Re: [50g] Re: time for a change

2008-07-28 by Daniel Stripes

On Saturday 26 July 2008 05:08:34 Guy Teague wrote:

> if you guys are getting tired of my little mini-rants and reviews of this
> calc (seeing as how we are, after all, on an hp50 list) just let me know.

I, for one, am definitely not tired of your commentary. On the contrary,
although I haven't the free time (like so many others - full-time job,
full-time university student, part-time husband, family member and homeowner)
to dig into the software, I have been reading your messages to this list and
look forward to continuing to read of your experience, observations,
evaluation, and comparison of this calculator to the likes of the 50g.

> but i think many or perhaps most of us have multiple calculators and are
> interested in all the brands and models.

That is certainly true in my case.

> for those interested i found the following site has some extremely helpful
> videos of many ti-nspire procedures and their coin toss programming example
> was extremely easy for me to modify for this dice toss program:
>
> http://movies.atomiclearning.com/k12/ti_nspire/

I haven't got to this yet, but I will eventually.

> /guy

Thank you for your time and energy spent evaluating and candidly sharing your
findings and opinions with us here.

Re: time for a change

2008-07-28 by George

TI-NSpire & CAS version have a just released verion 1.4 OS.
Updated NSpire computer software as well.

George

--- In 50g@yahoogroups.com, Daniel Stripes <analogtek@...> wrote:
>
> On Saturday 26 July 2008 05:08:34 Guy Teague wrote:
>
> > if you guys are getting tired of my little mini-rants and reviews
of this
> > calc (seeing as how we are, after all, on an hp50 list) just let
me know.
>
> I, for one, am definitely not tired of your commentary. On the
contrary,
> although I haven't the free time (like so many others - full-time
job,
> full-time university student, part-time husband, family member and
homeowner)
> to dig into the software, I have been reading your messages to this
list and
> look forward to continuing to read of your experience,
observations,
> evaluation, and comparison of this calculator to the likes of the
50g.
>
> > but i think many or perhaps most of us have multiple calculators
and are
> > interested in all the brands and models.
>
> That is certainly true in my case.
>
> > for those interested i found the following site has some
extremely helpful
> > videos of many ti-nspire procedures and their coin toss
programming example
> > was extremely easy for me to modify for this dice toss program:
> >
> > http://movies.atomiclearning.com/k12/ti_nspire/
>
> I haven't got to this yet, but I will eventually.
>
> > /guy
>
> Thank you for your time and energy spent evaluating and candidly
sharing your
> findings and opinions with us here.
>