50g group photo

Yahoo Groups archive

50g

Archive for 50g.

Index last updated: 2026-03-30 00:59 UTC

Thread

Re: [50g] Digest Number 178

Re: [50g] Digest Number 178

2008-07-21 by Cary Enoch R... aka Enoch's Vision, Inc.

> 1a. Re: HP 27S Solver & HP 50g Solve
> Posted by: "Guy Teague" accts@... gteague

> hp used to be renowned for their quality and it was a sad day to see 'made
> in singapore' on an hp27s i bought although it's still one of my favorite
> calculators as to operation even though it literally eats expensive
> batteries and you can barely see the display. i wonder if any of the folks
> praising the 'quality' of the hp50 have even worked on an hp35, 45, 55 &c.
> the new hp35 're-issue' was a welcome attempt and it indeed brings back fond
> memories of when hp wrote the book on calculator quality, but the interface
> and programming are not good and i myself found a bug in it and when it
> comes down to me finding a bug hp missed, they are indeed in trouble.

Why does "made in Singapore" distress you?

HP calculators have been manufactured in Singapore in addition to other places for more
than the past 30 years. Singapore has world class manufacturing facilities and a highly
skilled workforce. Singapore is a source of Intel CPUs and numerous primary components
from other manufacturers also.

It was actually more profitable for HP to ship calculator components from California and
Oregon to Asia. They were assembled there and then returned to the USA for packaging and
final shipment. That practice is no different than those of nearly any other
manufacturer you can name, whether their corporate headquarters are in the US or Japan.
Today the world's cheapest manufacturing comes from China which is also the major
dumping ground for all the toxic byproducts of electronics manufacturing.

[ sidebar: I worked for HP/Corvallis in 1983, and for Intel from 1984-1991. ]

I believe the last model that HP manufactured mostly in the USA was the HP67. Underneath
the keyboard, there was a entirely different design. Each key essentially floated in a
three-part cup-like structure. If you spilled a small amount of liquid on the keyboard,
you could just turn it over and shake it out. The HP41 and the HP12/15/16 series sported
cheaper and less sturdy snap disk keys (basically just a thin sheet with aluminum
protrusions under the keys).

The HP49 was designed by Kinpo Electronics, Inc. At one time HP's calculators were their
most profitable product. They were designed by the Advanced Products Division in
Corvallis, Oregon. I believe it is just a minor profit center now if at all.

Explore: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/HP_calculators

--
Cary Enoch Reinstein... aka enochsvision, Enoch's Vision Inc.
Art--Photography http://www.enochsvision.com Baha'i History: http://www.viewsofakka.com
Blog: http://enochsvision.wordpress.com Videos: http://www.youtube.com/enochsvision9
Behind all these manifestations is the one radiance, which shines through all things.
The function of art is to reveal this radiance through the created object. - Joseph Campbell

Re: [50g] Digest Number 178

2008-07-21 by Guy Teague

On Mon, Jul 21, 2008 at 8:21 AM, Cary Enoch R... aka Enoch's Vision, Inc. <caryenochr@...> wrote:
Why does "made in Singapore" distress you?

i guess you  have to be of the age when 'made in america' meant something special. it just seemed the end of an era for hp, a prototypical american company. hp quality was renowned, the world standard. nearly every piece of test equipment i used in the navy was hp. for them to compromise in any way just seemed a betrayal of all they stood for.
 

HP calculators have been manufactured in Singapore in addition to other places for more
than the past 30 years. Singapore has world class manufacturing facilities and a highly
skilled workforce. Singapore is a source of Intel CPUs and numerous primary components
from other manufacturers also.

<del>

and today there is no stigma (or little) re overseas manufacture. i personally never envision buying another american car, ever. and i distrust the japanese cars which are manufactured here.

/guy
 
--
Cary Enoch Reinstein...  aka enochsvision, Enoch's Vision Inc.
Art--Photography http://www.enochsvision.com  Baha'i History: http://www.viewsofakka.com
Blog: http://enochsvision.wordpress.com  Videos: http://www.youtube.com/enochsvision9
Behind all these manifestations is the one radiance, which shines through all things.
The function of art is to reveal this radiance through the created object. - Joseph Campbell


Re: Digest Number 178

2008-07-22 by Sundaresa Venkatraman

I suppose free trade and open markets have meaning only when it is advantageous
to America. Mr Teague, wake up to the new flat world!

I find the 50g made in China or Singapore no less in quality than the 48g+ made in
USA. HP's quality control is still legendary. By going global HP has contained the cost
and increased profitability. I see nothing wrong with that.

--- In 50g@yahoogroups.com, "Guy Teague" <accts@...> wrote:
>
> On Mon, Jul 21, 2008 at 8:21 AM, Cary Enoch R... aka Enoch's Vision, Inc. <
> caryenochr@...> wrote:
>
> > Why does "made in Singapore" distress you?
> >
>
> i guess you have to be of the age when 'made in america' meant something
> special. it just seemed the end of an era for hp, a prototypical american
> company. hp quality was renowned, the world standard. nearly every piece of
> test equipment i used in the navy was hp. for them to compromise in any way
> just seemed a betrayal of all they stood for.
>
>
> >
> > HP calculators have been manufactured in Singapore in addition to other
> > places for more
> > than the past 30 years. Singapore has world class manufacturing facilities
> > and a highly
> > skilled workforce. Singapore is a source of Intel CPUs and numerous primary
> > components
> > from other manufacturers also.
> >
> > <del>
> >
>
> and today there is no stigma (or little) re overseas manufacture. i
> personally never envision buying another american car, ever. and i distrust
> the japanese cars which are manufactured here.
>
> /guy
>
>
> > --
> > Cary Enoch Reinstein... aka enochsvision, Enoch's Vision Inc.
> > Art--Photography http://www.enochsvision.com Baha'i History:
> > http://www.viewsofakka.com
> > Blog: http://enochsvision.wordpress.com Videos:
> > http://www.youtube.com/enochsvision9
> > Behind all these manifestations is the one radiance, which shines through
> > all things.
> > The function of art is to reveal this radiance through the created object.
> > - Joseph Campbell
> >
> >
>

Re: [50g] Re: Digest Number 178

2008-07-22 by jrc

For SV and all, most of whom have no knowledge base whatever -

Anyone who says 'HP quality control is still legendary' has either not been
exposed to later HP products - including the disasters begun by the
Australian 'operation' - or never saw a real HP-furnished lab in the
older days. What nonsense.

Mr SV - frankly, 'free trade and open markets' have little to do with
quality in today's world. If it was truly 'free', things would be much
different. 'Quality' is no longer even a major bargaining chip.

That TI is in fact 'competitive' with HP is a giveaway that HP
quality is long-gone. HP printers are another example of typical,
low-quality product lines.

- a user of HP calculators from the 35 on.

jrc

Sundaresa Venkatraman wrote:
>
> I suppose free trade and open markets have meaning only when it is
> advantageous
> to America. Mr Teague, wake up to the new flat world!
>
> I find the 50g made in China or Singapore no less in quality than the
> 48g+ made in
> USA. HP's quality control is still legendary. By going global HP has
> contained the cost
> and increased profitability. I see nothing wrong with that.
>
> --- In 50g@yahoogroups.com <mailto:50g%40yahoogroups.com>, "Guy
> Teague" <accts@...> wrote:
> >
> > On Mon, Jul 21, 2008 at 8:21 AM, Cary Enoch R... aka Enoch's Vision,
> Inc. <
> > caryenochr@...> wrote:
> >
> > > Why does "made in Singapore" distress you?
> > >
> >
> > i guess you have to be of the age when 'made in america' meant something
> > special. it just seemed the end of an era for hp, a prototypical
> american
> > company. hp quality was renowned, the world standard. nearly every
> piece of
> > test equipment i used in the navy was hp. for them to compromise in
> any way
> > just seemed a betrayal of all they stood for.
> >
> >
> > >
> > > HP calculators have been manufactured in Singapore in addition to
> other
> > > places for more
> > > than the past 30 years. Singapore has world class manufacturing
> facilities
> > > and a highly
> > > skilled workforce. Singapore is a source of Intel CPUs and
> numerous primary
> > > components
> > > from other manufacturers also.
> > >
> > > <del>
> > >
> >
> > and today there is no stigma (or little) re overseas manufacture. i
> > personally never envision buying another american car, ever. and i
> distrust
> > the japanese cars which are manufactured here.
> >
> > /guy
> >
> >
> > > --
> > > Cary Enoch Reinstein... aka enochsvision, Enoch's Vision Inc.
> > > Art--Photography http://www.enochsvision.com
> <http://www.enochsvision.com> Baha'i History:
> > > http://www.viewsofakka.com <http://www.viewsofakka.com>
> > > Blog: http://enochsvision.wordpress.com
> <http://enochsvision.wordpress.com> Videos:
> > > http://www.youtube.com/enochsvision9
> <http://www.youtube.com/enochsvision9>
> > > Behind all these manifestations is the one radiance, which shines
> through
> > > all things.
> > > The function of art is to reveal this radiance through the created
> object.
> > > - Joseph Campbell
> > >
> > >
> >
>
>

Re: Digest Number 178

2008-07-23 by arthurford4142

> On Mon, Jul 21, 2008 at 8:21 AM, Cary Enoch R... aka Enoch's Vision,
Inc. <
> caryenochr@...> wrote:
>
> > Why does "made in Singapore" distress you?
> >
>
> i guess you have to be of the age when 'made in america' meant
something
> special. it just seemed the end of an era for hp, a prototypical
american
> company. hp quality was renowned, the world standard. nearly every
piece of
> test equipment i used in the navy was hp. for them to compromise in
any way
> just seemed a betrayal of all they stood for.
>
Oh, you've got me reminiscing here. Back in the day, 40 some years
ago, my military unit had all top of the line test equipment -
everything mil-spec. To be honest, I don't remember the brand names of
any except one. We spent a lot of time with our oscilloscopes. If you
wanted a GOOD o'scope, you had 3 choices: Tektronix, Tektronix, or
Tektronix. Check out the Wikipedia on Tektronix:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tektronix
Check out the sentence with the phrase "very highest quality". The
only other company mentioned is HP.
Yea, it was special; you couldn't buy anything better.
BTW, I am now the proud new owner of a really nice Cannondale bicycle,
handmade in the USA.

Re: Digest Number 178

2008-07-27 by walshingham2000

Yes I can remember the HP35 and HP45.... good build quality. I don't
really want to get into the pros and cons of manufacturing locations,
however as suggested its all about maximizing bottom line profit.

Take for example the totally inadequate manual and documentation that
comes with the HP50g.. and compare it if you remember to the quality
of the manuals that accompanied both the HP35 and Hp45..

Another example of how to maximize profit...

Walsh





--- In 50g@yahoogroups.com, "Cary Enoch R... aka Enoch's Vision, Inc."
<caryenochr@...> wrote:
>
> > 1a. Re: HP 27S Solver & HP 50g Solve
> > Posted by: "Guy Teague" accts@... gteague
>
> > hp used to be renowned for their quality and it was a sad day to
see 'made
> > in singapore' on an hp27s i bought although it's still one of my
favorite
> > calculators as to operation even though it literally eats expensive
> > batteries and you can barely see the display. i wonder if any of
the folks
> > praising the 'quality' of the hp50 have even worked on an hp35,
45, 55 &c.
> > the new hp35 're-issue' was a welcome attempt and it indeed brings
back fond
> > memories of when hp wrote the book on calculator quality, but the
interface
> > and programming are not good and i myself found a bug in it and
when it
> > comes down to me finding a bug hp missed, they are indeed in trouble.
>
> Why does "made in Singapore" distress you?
>
> HP calculators have been manufactured in Singapore in addition to
other places for more
> than the past 30 years. Singapore has world class manufacturing
facilities and a highly
> skilled workforce. Singapore is a source of Intel CPUs and numerous
primary components
> from other manufacturers also.
>
> It was actually more profitable for HP to ship calculator components
from California and
> Oregon to Asia. They were assembled there and then returned to the
USA for packaging and
> final shipment. That practice is no different than those of nearly
any other
> manufacturer you can name, whether their corporate headquarters are
in the US or Japan.
> Today the world's cheapest manufacturing comes from China which is
also the major
> dumping ground for all the toxic byproducts of electronics
manufacturing.
>
> [ sidebar: I worked for HP/Corvallis in 1983, and for Intel from
1984-1991. ]
>
> I believe the last model that HP manufactured mostly in the USA was
the HP67. Underneath
> the keyboard, there was a entirely different design. Each key
essentially floated in a
> three-part cup-like structure. If you spilled a small amount of
liquid on the keyboard,
> you could just turn it over and shake it out. The HP41 and the
HP12/15/16 series sported
> cheaper and less sturdy snap disk keys (basically just a thin sheet
with aluminum
> protrusions under the keys).
>
> The HP49 was designed by Kinpo Electronics, Inc. At one time HP's
calculators were their
> most profitable product. They were designed by the Advanced Products
Division in
> Corvallis, Oregon. I believe it is just a minor profit center now if
at all.
>
> Explore: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/HP_calculators
>
> --
> Cary Enoch Reinstein... aka enochsvision, Enoch's Vision Inc.
> Art--Photography http://www.enochsvision.com Baha'i History:
http://www.viewsofakka.com
> Blog: http://enochsvision.wordpress.com Videos:
http://www.youtube.com/enochsvision9
> Behind all these manifestations is the one radiance, which shines
through all things.
> The function of art is to reveal this radiance through the created
object. - Joseph Campbell
>