At one time I intended to be a purist and not buy any module containing
a microprocessor. Part of my reticence was due to the lack of kits in
this genre. That didn't last long. First I bought an Encore Frequency
Shifter. Then of course a MOTM-650. Added to my collection now are the
Encore UEG, Modcan Dual Quantizer, Modcan CV Recorder, and, soon, the
Modcan VCDO. Of course I want a Cloud Generator too! I probably
represent a small customer niche, but what I like about such modules is
that they sport analog-like user interfaces (the MOTM-650 not
withstanding its menu system). I like being able to set up modules
using knobs and buttons. I do not wish to hook up a computer to my MOTM
to control it. (I did try it to get a MIDI soft sequencer going - oh
the pain - the pain of trying to control my MOTM with a mouse.) If you
wander on over to the Modcan website and check out the latest Modcan B
module, you can see the analog interface trend being continued there.
The Quad Envelope Generator 60B contains 4 digital envelope generators,
each with 6 parameters. It's is programmed with 6 knobs and 3 buttons,
with a few LEDs to keep track of where you are. I like that sort of
interface! It is clean and simple, and powerful. Settings are saved
between power cycles. So you have a small programmable module without
any screen, even an LCD. I'm impressed. I like this trend, and I hope
Paul takes note. I'm not opposed to an LCD if there is room. I don't
mind embedded microprocessors. But you can see why I lurked silently
over the thread about how to extend the Cloud Generator be controlled by
USB, MIDI, Ethernet, Bluetooth and iPhone. Give me some knobs and
switches. I'm old fashioned. I love to kick back and play without
having to boot up a computer.
If this seemed like a rant, it wasn't. There are many ways to control a
synthesizer and using a computer is a valid one. I'm just offering a
point of view.
Richard Brewster
http://www.pugix.com