Archive of the former Yahoo!Groups mailing list: Homebrew PCBs

previous by date index next by date
previous in topic topic list next in topic

Subject: Re: [Homebrew_PCBs] Re: EDM -- further thoughts.Which book to Buy?

From: "Tony Smith" <ajsmith@...>
Date: 2005-08-04

I've thought about PCB etching with EDM, I figured it would work ok, but
be a bit slow.

People mill PCBs, that's slow & noisy! At least EDM is quiet.

Considering the small amount of material you need to remove, the results
might surprise you. After all, electricity is a good way of removing
metal. Most of us have screwdrivers or probes with bits missing (usually
after testing capacitors!), that's a good bit of metal removed in a short
time.

I'd be interested in the final result (quality, speed, minimum trace etc),
but I doubt I'll ever make PCBs this way, but I'm happy to keep it in
mind. The info could come in handy for other projects, etching
nameplates, etc.

Tony



> I see no reason to use EDM for PCB mechanical etching. It sounds
> like an insane idea. Mike
>
>
> --- In Homebrew_PCBs@yahoogroups.com, Curtis Richards
> wrote:
> > Richard Mcfarlane wrote:
> >
> > >Dear Moderator Mr. Curtis Richards,
> > > Many thanks for your useful EDM information.
> > >I like to buy one of the EDM books you mentioned
> > >below.Which one would be better? I wish to build a CNC
> > >Wire /Sinker EDM with PWM- EDM Power Supply:-
> > >1. How to EDM Book--By Mr.Ben Fleming (20 USD)
> > >2. S-EDM for the Homeshop--By Practice Publication
> > > Price -Not mentioned and from where to get this
> > >book?Is this the very same EDM(Robert Langlois) book
> > >by Home Shop Machinist? I have this book.But this is