The Mellotron Group group photo

Yahoo Groups archive

The Mellotron Group

Archive for newmellotrongroup.v1.

Index last updated: 2026-03-30 01:16 UTC

Message

Re: Top 10 Worst Keyboards

2007-12-01 by Tony Swettenham

--- In newmellotrongroup@yahoogroups.com, MAinPsych@... wrote:
>
> Almost forgot to nominate the infamous Hohner Pianet. It was the
only thing
> our keyboard player had in the early '70's and I absolutely hated it,
> particularly when we played "Won't Get Fooled Again". Power chords
with backing from
> the neighborhood ice cream truck!
>
> Frank 1
>

I remember playing a Hohner Pianet T a few times, many years ago. The
sound wasn't *too* bad compared to some, but the feel was hideous. I
remember reading somewhere that it had a somewhat Heath
Robinson-sounding 'suction-based' action (suction pads plucking metal
reeds as the keys were pressed), which doesn't altogether surprise me.

And who can forget the Gem (?) foldaway 'Insta-Piano'? Well, I nearly
did - maybe the one I once borrowed was a duff one but that one
certainly had all the character and clarity of cotton wool, only less
well-tuned. Perhaps there might just be better examples of that in
existence but I've yet to encounter one!


Tony S
M400S # 581

Attachments