CD shelf-life (was: Digital recording and the Mac Mini)
2005-01-13 by Scott Gibbons
>> More food for thought: I have to keep multiple copies of my digital >> projects, because there's a rather limited life expectancy for a CDR, DVD, >> or hard drive. > Might I inquire where you get this information? I remember hearing something > similiar in the late 80s that "CDs won't last longer than 10-15 years", but This is all 2° hand... I've only ever had one CD go bad, and that was because of CD rot on a commercial disc -- which is the revelation that you're remembering; the dyes in the early runs were found to be eating away at the CD itself... AFAIK that was resolved worldwide by the mid-90's. But there are other issues still at play. It's impossible to produce a consistently airtight CD, and especially to MASS produce. If you handle and store a disc properly, the studies suggest that the average CDR will last 20 years or more. Maybe up to 200 years -- which slays hard drive storage!! But if the disc is faulty, maybe you can expect 2-5 years before oxidation causes irreversible damage. No-name discs that come on spindles are particularly succeptible to this because the manufacturing quality is much less consistent; they use lowest-cost components and older machines in manufacturing. Anyway. That's what "they say." I keep my (name brand, quality) CD's away from light, in stable temperature & humity, and am always careful when handling them. And - knock on wood - I've lost hard drives before, but never one of my CDR's. Unfortunately, I have thousands of gigs of material archived, and CDR / DVD isn't really an option for all that... So I keep multiple hard drives and transfer the data to fresh drives every few years. Anyway, with CDR's you definitely get what you pay for, and Mitsui Gold DOES have better longevity than Bob's Back Alley Spindles. But the bottom line is: NOTHING IS EVER REALLY BACKED UP UNLESS IT EXISTS IN 3 DIFFERENT PLACES! Words to live by, learned in part from experience (big F-U Syquest!) best, - Scott ____________ http://www.red-noise.com http://www.strawberryplanet.org