a) I think that the discussion is mainly for continuing the Stooge panels. Production MOTM panels will remain as they are (even as such a pain as they are) simply because changing this late in the game (6500+ shipped) doesn't make sense. The slight cost savings to me is overshadowed by having a completely different finish. b) anodized panels *will* show fingerprints. Which is odd is that the rougher the initial finish (aluminum is belt-sanded before painting/plating), the more likely anodized panels will show prints. You can get glossy anodizing and you can 'overcoat' with a clear finish. For example, I think the Millennia Media Origin is drop-dead gorgeous and it's anodized: http://www.mil-media.com/docs/products/origin.shtml For painted panels, having a textured finish (which is a special nozzle that 'splatters' the paint) *reduces* fingerprints (and glare). c) anodizing is sensitive to the aluminum. Most people do not realize that there are about 8 *different* alloys of aluminum. The most common (and what is used on MOTM now) is called 5052-H3. However, anodized aluminum is better with a *different* alloy called 6061-T6. Of course, 6061-T6 is about 15% more cost that 5052 (6061-T6 is commonly used on hang gliders and small aircraft). Blacet panels are anodized, 120 grit sanded, 6061-T6 aluminum. As well as Moog modular panels (they are sanded to a finer grain, around 320 grit). Also, the current press-fitting PEM studs and standoffs (on the rear of the panels) have a tougher time gripping 6061. A solution is to eliminate the older black pc brackets (that use threaded PEMs and KEPS nuts to attach to the panel) for 100% Stooge brackets (the silver ones that fasten behind the pot nuts). This still leaves issues with the 900, 950, 600 and 650, though :( d) I really don't see a point to changing, just for the sake of "fancier" graphics like the CMS modular: http://machines.hyperreal.org/manufacturers/CMS/Modular/images/mc24b.jpg without having to jack up the price. I think Paul H. is trying to find a solution +-10% of what I am paying now for say 50 pieces at a time, that now I can only fab say 7 pieces. The reasoning behind *this* is that there are some...errr..."slow selling" modules that may need 14 panels/year. Certainly, that CMS modular is quite a sight to behold, but so is the pricetag :) So, official MOTM panels will remain as they are for 2006. For DIY/Stooge panels, those can be whatever is best in terms of cost and delivery. Stooge panels are a 'pretty big business' and help to promote the MOTM form factor as the leading industry standard in 1/4" jacks. If I do decide to make a change, it will be 'radical' like the Modcan Series B: something removed far away from the original. Let's face it: I never dreamed of selling 6500 of these things in the first place. I was hoping for 500 so I could get a good stereo :) Paul S.
Message
My initial take on the panel discussion
2005-12-02 by Paul Schreiber
Attachments
- No local attachments were found for this message.