Yahoo Groups archive

MOTM

Index last updated: 2026-04-09 22:55 UTC

Message

Re: Electrolytic Cap Placement & Solder

1999-11-21 by Paul Schreiber

>
> I'm stuffing compenents in all my boards for the first pass solder/wash.
I
> normally mount electrolytic capacitors firmly up against the PCB.  After
> reading about the problems of organic flux residue, I am wondering how I
am
> going to clean under under them.  Does it matter if I can't clean under
them?
>  Or do I need to keep a centimeter or so space, so I can clean

Actually, the hole spacing is about 0.025 *wider* then 'spec' to make the
caps "stand up"
off the pcb about 1/32" so the water will flow under there. Note the "yellow
box caps"
have small cutouts for this purpose.


> Is the only  reason we are not using good old rosin core 63/37 solder
because it leaves
> unsightly flux marks?

There are two reasons MOTM does not use rosin core solder (in fact, no one
has used rosin-core solder
*in mass production* since about 1990).

#1 - rosin is designed to *attract moisture* (think of the rosin bag in
baseball, and in gymnastics). Attracting
moisture in *NOT* what we want in synths! Especially VCOs.

#2 - in order to *remove* the rosin off the boards, you need *horribly
messy* chemicals. Freon was the older
choice. There are spray cans of non-CFC rosin flux remover, but my
experience is that this makes a huge
mess because all you do is dissolve the flux and coat the whole pcb with it!
In production lines in the '70s/'80s
there were massive, high-power water jets that 'scrubbed' the flux off with
150 psi water nozzels after a good old Freon
bath (the boards were actually immersed in liquid Freon).

Today, *all* soldering is using "No Clean" flux.

So, a fair question is :"Why not use No Clean everywhere?"

The answer is that I felt that No Clean is harder to solder, and that
organic *still* has the best overall
joint construction. The only reason No Clean replaced organic is that the
manufacturers saved millions
of dollars on water bills (and floor space!).

Paul S.

Attachments

Move to quarantaine

This moves the raw source file on disk only. The archive index is not changed automatically, so you still need to run a manual refresh afterward.