Hello, Last week, I installed milter-greylist for some email addresses. Last night, the file /var/milter-greylist/greylist.db displays: ---------------------- Sample 1 ----------------------------------- [ .... ] 222.136.25.31 <virginia@...> <xxxx.xxxxxxxx@...> 1085536020 # 2004-05-26 03:47:00 24.60.250.191 <ssu@...> <xxxx.xxxxxxxx@...> 1085536023 # 2004-05-26 03:47:03 24.98.118.46 <derrek@...> <xxxx.xxxxxxxx@...> 1085536025 # 2004-05-26 03:47:05 24.34.148.233 <sakti@...> <xxxx.xxxxxxxx@...> 1085536029 # 2004-05-26 03:47:09 61.84.231.102 <gaoyuan@...> <xxxx.xxxxxxxx@...> 1085536033 # 2004-05-26 03:47:13 61.249.203.23 <icap@...> <xxxx.xxxxxxxx@...> 1085536039 # 2004-05-26 03:47:19 4.7.50.95 <randall@...> <xxxx.xxxxxxxx@...> 1085536048 # 2004-05-26 03:47:28 65.24.194.20 <subhednu@...> <xxxx.xxxxxxxx@...> 1085536050 # 2004-05-26 03:47:30 66.188.95.20 <gene@...> <xxxx.xxxxxxxx@...> 1085536076 # 2004-05-26 03:47:56 67.163.217.46 <dryden@...> <xxxx.xxxxxxxx@...> 1085536077 # 2004-05-26 03:47:57 67.162.129.13 <somasama@...> <xxxx.xxxxxxxx@...> 1085536079 # 2004-05-26 03:47:59 [ .... ] ---------------------- Sample 2 ----------------------------------- 200.53.248.142 <libpcap@...> <yyyyyy@...> 1085544283 # 2004-05-26 06:04:43 24.16.253.21 <tudor@...> <yyyyyy@...> 1085544284 # 2004-05-26 06:04:44 24.157.153.40 <cmsg@...> <yyyyyy@...> 1085544361 # 2004-05-26 06:06:01 24.159.241.11 <orlandini@...> <yyyyyy@...> 1085544364 # 2004-05-26 06:06:04 200.82.47.94 <Soille@...> <yyyyyy@...> 1085544372 # 2004-05-26 06:06:12 24.128.119.17 <Qobi@...> <yyyyyy@...> 1085544378 # 2004-05-26 06:06:18 24.14.26.219 <jamesm@...> <yyyyyy@...> 1085544379 # 2004-05-26 06:06:19 218.48.37.81 <abiword_bugs@...> <yyyyyy@...> 1085544384 # 2004-05-26 06:06:24 24.130.151.178 <snowhare@...> <yyyyyy@...> 1085544388 # 2004-05-26 06:06:28 [ ... 600 lines deleted : from 06:04:43 to 07:10:23 ] Here 600 is a big number, but VERY OFTEN I have 20-30 connections in 2 minutes for a SINGLE destination, but from 20-30 differents IP and differents From:. My interpretation: a spammer wants to send something to <yyyyyy@...>, it fails from 200.53.248.142 / <libpcap@...>, and so he retries from another PC within a pool of "relays", and so on. So there are 2 denies of service: . large amount of SMTP connections in a short time (= fork with sendmail); . large amount of data collected in the greylist database. Question: isn't that the perfect tool to destroy the idea of greylisting? -- Jacques Beigbeder | Jacques.Beigbeder@... Service de Prestations Informatiques | http://www.spi.ens.fr Ecole normale sup\ufffdrieure | 45 rue d'Ulm |Tel : (+33 1)1 44 32 37 96 F75230 Paris cedex 05 |Fax : (+33 1)1 44 32 20 75
Message
is this a DoS?
2004-05-26 by Jacques Beigbeder
Attachments
- No local attachments were found for this message.