Yahoo Groups archive

Milter-greylist

Index last updated: 2026-04-28 23:32 UTC

Message

Re: [milter-greylist] Few questions.

2006-01-22 by Sysadmin

Hello.
> I'm not aware that milter-greylist can be compiled with
> db4 support.  :-)
>   
It is, check the configure options.
> No, it doesn't.  Why should it?  It is just replaced at
> regular intervals (I set that to 10 minutes on my servers)
> and when the process receives a SIGTERM.
>   
Mine is aslo set to 10 minutes, so let it be so, I also enabled the 
lazyaw option and hoped that the memoryusage will dropp, but didn't see 
any changes atleast in dump file same all (Sender IP Sender e-mail 
Recipient e-mail Time accepted) there, for me the sender ip/mail is good 
enaugh.
> There are quite a lot of greylist implementations.  Let
> me explain why I chose milter-greylist from all of them.
>
> My primary MX is a Dual-Celeron-450 with 160 Mbyte RAM,
> my secondary MX is a 486-DX2-66 with 32 Mbyte RAM.  So
> the hardware resources are quite limited.
>   
Is so, then ok.
> Most of the greylist implementatios are written in Perl
> and use an SQL backend (mostly MySQL).  That's horribly
> inefficient and completely out of the question.
>
> I found two implementations written in C and without the
> SQL DB requirement:  The one from ACME:
>    http://www.acme.com/mail_filtering/
> and the one from Emmanuel Dreyfus:
>    http://hcpnet.free.fr/milter-greylist/
>
> The ACME implementation has only very few features and
> doesn't even write anything to disk.  So when you kill
> the process, the greylist is lost.  That's why I decided
> to give Emmanuel's milter-greylist a try.
>   
I'v have been using graymilter in some computers, with domain patch, as 
the original code accepts in initialwhitelist ip -s only, but since I 
need to whitelist whole country domain prefix, I can't use the original 
code.
> So far I'm quite satisfied, except for the the problem
> I explained in a nother mail ("unknown users" being
> greylisted), but that cannot easily be solved, so it's
> not really the fault of milter-greylist.
>
> Also, there seems to be a memory leak.  Especially on
> my 32Mbyte machine I see the milter process growing
> quite fast, even though only a small portion of it
> stays resident in memory.  When I kill and restart it,
> the process is smaller, even though it contains the
> same greylist.  My current work-around is to kill and
> restart milter-greylist regularly via cron.
>
>   
Havent notice leak yet on 2.0.2 and asap if someone shows me the way how 
to compile the latest version, I'll give try.

-- 
Sysadmin

Attachments

Move to quarantaine

This moves the raw source file on disk only. The archive index is not changed automatically, so you still need to run a manual refresh afterward.