Mellotronists group photo

Yahoo Groups archive

Mellotronists

Index last updated: 2026-04-28 23:09 UTC

Thread

YES & Rick

YES & Rick

2002-05-08 by JS

I'm gonna have to throw my two cents in - as a Rick look-alike and sound-alike for 30-odd years, there is no other human and group who have influenced me like those guys (except maybe for Kirk, Spock, McCoy, Scotty, and the rest of the gang) and who can still give me chills like they do. I would KILL to experience again the sense of wonder, awe, and delight ;that listening to so much of their music for the first time brought to me. For my taste, from "From the hills we viewed the silence of the valley" to the end bird twitters, the last few minutes of "Close to the Edge" is the most beautiful bit of music ever written, and after all these years still brings tears to my eyes and goosebumps to my flesh. And then there's "And You And I." My god, how can anybody who even just sort of likes Mellotrons not be bowled over by that song? ; While "Tales" may be a bit meandering at times, it has several moments in it that are of almost equal strength to me - from Wakeman's screaming MiniMoog solo to the end of side one, the end of side two featuring the first Wakeman 8-voice choir appearance in Yes, like a choir of enormous Yes angels (not counting the little "Six Wives" excerpt and "Hallelujah Chorus" on Yessongs,) the incredible Dante-esque fury of side three, the quiet beauty of "Nous Sommes du Soleil" - I don't know how those can be dismissed just because they are so exploratory. For cryin' out loud, most of the crap that was contemporaneous to that stuff was so intellectually and artistically limp, I'm amazed those six guys were able to do what they did on those two albums. Yes, the two best Yes albums. And while Tormato and Going for the One weren't the best Yes (sort of Yes-Lite for me), they still blow away "Drama" and "Relayer" for those who want to hear the classic Yes arrangement style. Sure, the music wasn't as carefully thought out, but by then, they had been turned into a formula-based product instead of a forward-thinking experimental rock band. And today? I firmly believe there will be a Yes band fifty years from now. Yes has turned into an entity with a life of its own, and I sincerely think Yes music will continue to provide the leadership in the art-prog-classical influences that rock music so benefits by. Yes will change, Yes will live. And as goes Yes, goes the Mellotron...

Jon E Salley
MiloJohnson@...
M400 #886

SV: [Mellotronists] YES & Rick

2002-05-08 by Ivens de Carvalho

>....
> what they did on those two albums. Yes, the two best Yes albums. And while Tormato and Going for the One weren't the best Yes (sort of Yes-Lite for me), they still blow away "Drama" and "Relayer" for those who want to hear the classic Yes arrangement style. Sure, the music wasn't as carefully thought out, but by then, they had been turned into a formula-based product instead of a forward-thinking experimental rock band. And today? I firmly believe there will be a Yes band fifty years from now. Yes has turned into an entity with a life of its own, and I sincerely think Yes music will continue to provide the leadership in the art-prog-classical influences that rock music so benefits by. Yes will change, Yes will live. And as goes Yes, goes the Mellotron...
[Ivens de Carvalho]
Amen! I agree with you entirely. Glad to hear from someone else that holds Tales, Relayer and not least Drama so highly. And I agree that I also found Going for the One to be Yes-lite,
despite the undisputable qualities of 'Awaken'. Honestly, Tales is such a big mellotron-album.
So many shades of the tron sound to be found there. And I am glad they took a chance and stretched it out over two discs. Long live experimentation!
And Relayer continued the tron magic (and didn't Moraz also use an orchestron BTW?). Just the backing sounds at the end of 'To be Over'. It's still magic to me!
Frank Carvalho

SV: [Mellotronists] YES & Rick

2002-05-08 by Ivens de Carvalho

> And while Tormato and Going for the One weren't the best Yes (sort of Yes-Lite for me), they still blow away "Drama" and "Relayer" for those who want to hear the classic Yes arrangement style.
and I said:
>Glad to hear from someone else that holds Tales, Relayer and not least >Drama so highly
I just realize that's not exactly what you were saying.....
So I'll stay within the minority here. Drama and Relayer are exceptional albums I think.

Frank

Re: [Mellotronists] YES & Rick

2002-05-09 by Chris Dale

I agree as well. Close To The Edge is both a milestone and a masterpiece. I like Tales too, but I'm not always in the mood to listen to the whole thing straight through. Sometimes I'll play my favourite parts. I never got into Relayer as much, but I still like Going For The One especially because of Awaken. I've actually never heard Tormato but I did hear Drama and it was okay, just not as captivating as the early stuff. The early 70's seems to be Yes' strongest period. Close To The Edge was one of my first introductions to the mellotron too, so of course I have a soft spot for it, even regardless of having the surviving double tron. I'm thinking particularly of I Get Up, I Get Down, which for me, is one of my all time favourite mellotron moments, alongside the atmospheres in Awaken.
Another thing I like is the lyrics. It's nice not to hear teenage angst horndog lyrics for once. I know of some young kids in my old neighbourhood who have dissected those lyrics, and consequently looked words up in the dictionary, and picked up a few
good books because of the influence of the lyrics. Good for them I say. It's a much needed antidote to the mindless swill being shoved down kids throats by radio, T.V. and magazines.
If a top 10 mellotron band list were taken, Yes would certainly make it for me. Granted I don't like everything in the Yes catalogue, but then there isn't any band, I don't care who - Crimson, Moodies, Genesis, ELP, etc. who haven't made their share of bad music. Even the Beatles have several duds.
One thing I do credit Yes with doing is keeping the mellotron flame alive for more than a decade. All the other well known prog bands (except maybe the Moodies) gave up on it during the 80's. So I welcome the return of Wakeman to Yes. Any band that can make adventurous music, and has the passion for it, even if it doesn't always turn out for the best, has my respect and admiration for not being afraid to try in the first place.
Chris Dale
Show quoted textHide quoted text
----- Original Message -----
From: JS
Sent: Wednesday, May 08, 2002 4:19 PM
Subject: [Mellotronists] YES & Rick

I'm gonna have to throw my two cents in - as a Rick look-alike and sound-alike for 30-odd years, there is no other human and group who have influenced me like those guys (except maybe for Kirk, Spock, McCoy, Scotty, and the rest of the gang) and who can still give me chills like they do. I would KILL to experience again the sense of wonder, awe, and delight that listening to so much of their music for the first time brought to me. ;For my taste, from "From the hills we viewed the silence of the valley" to the end bird twitters, the last few minutes of "Close to the Edge" is the most beautiful bit of music ever written, and after all these years still brings tears to my eyes and goosebumps to my flesh. And then there's "And You And I." My god, how can anybody who even just sort of likes Mellotrons not be bowled over by that song? While "Tales" may be a bit meandering at times, it has several moments in it that are of almost equal strength to me - from Wakeman's screaming MiniMoog solo to the end of side one, the end of side two featuring the first Wakeman 8-voice choir appearance in Yes, like a choir of enormous Yes angels (not counting the little "Six Wives" excerpt and "Hallelujah Chorus" on Yessongs,) the incredible Dante-esque fury of side three, the quiet beauty of "Nous Sommes du Soleil" - I don't know how those can be dismissed just because they are so exploratory. For cryin' out loud, most of the crap that was contemporaneous to that stuff was so intellectually and artistically limp, I'm amazed those six guys were able to do what they did on those two albums. Yes, the two best Yes albums. And while Tormato and Going for the One weren't the best Yes (sort of Yes-Lite for me), they still blow away "Drama" and "Relayer" for those who want to hear the classic Yes arrangement style. Sure, the music wasn't as carefully thought out, but by then, they had been turned into a formula-based product instead of a forward-thinking experimental rock band. And today? I firmly believe there will be a Yes band fifty years from now. Yes has turned into an entity with a life of its own, and I sincerely think Yes music will continue to provide the leadership in the art-prog-classical influences that rock music so benefits by. Yes will change, Yes will live. And as goes Yes, goes the Mellotron...

Jon E Salley
MiloJohnson@...
M400 #886


To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:
Mellotronists-unsubscribe@yahoogroups.com



Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to the Yahoo! Terms of Service.

Re: [Mellotronists] YES & Rick

2002-05-09 by Phil Tortorici

> And while Tormato and Going for the One weren't the best Yes (sort of Yes-Lite for me), they still blow away "Drama" and "Relayer" for those who want to hear the classic Yes arrangement style.
and I said:
>Glad to hear from someone else that holds Tales, Relayer and not least >Drama so highly
I just realize that's not exactly what you were saying.....
So I'll stay within the minority here. Drama and Relayer are exceptional albums I think.

Frank


To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:
Mellotronists-unsubscribe@yahoogroups.com



Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to the Yahoo! Terms of Service.

RE: [Mellotronists] YES & Rick

2002-05-10 by Andy Thompson

-----Original Message-----
From: Chris Dale [mailto:chris.dale@...]
Sent: 09 May 2002 01:59
To: Mellotronists@yahoogroups.com; JS
Subject: Re: [Mellotronists] YES & Rick

Chris
One thing I do credit Yes with doing is keeping the mellotron flame alive for more than a decade. All the other well known prog bands (except maybe the Moodies) gave up on it during the 80's.
I didn't think they used any tape-replay after Rick's Birotron in '78?

Re: [Mellotronists] YES & Rick

2002-05-10 by Chris Dale

Hi Andy:
I thought that too, but there is Geoff Downes' Novatron strings on Drama (1980) mixed with the synths. There's also mellotron strings and flutes again on "I Would Have Waited Forever" from Union. If you're inclined - listen for the strings in the build up of the middle 8 section, and the flutes after the lyric "..For everything will come around " . Who knows - maybe the "everything will come around" lyric is a reference to the mellotron sound - an inside joke perhaps.
Again - listening with headphones in a quiet room at night is almost mandatory to hear it. According to an interview in Keyboard magazine, producer Jonathan Elias tried to goad Wakeman to play the part, and when Wakeman refused, decided to play it himself.
As for the Moodies, you can hear Patrick Moraz mellotron custom sound effects and strings on Long Distance Voyager. The synth intro of "The Voice" is mellotron and it appears throughout other songs which escape memory at the moment. In a 1984 interview, John Lodge admitted that even though the mellotron technology is outdated, they still liked it very much and were still using it. Apparently the last use of real mellotron for the Moodies was "Keys To The Kingdom" on tracks that Moraz played on.
Chris Dale
Show quoted textHide quoted text
----- Original Message -----
Sent: Thursday, May 09, 2002 8:04 PM
Subject: RE: [Mellotronists] YES & Rick

-----Original Message-----
From: Chris Dale [mailto:chris.dale@...]
Sent: 09 May 2002 01:59
To: Mellotronists@yahoogroups.com; JS
Subject: Re: [Mellotronists] YES & Rick

Chris
One thing I do credit Yes with doing is keeping the mellotron flame alive for more than a decade. All the other well known prog bands (except maybe the Moodies) gave up on it during the 80's.
I didn't think they used any tape-replay after Rick's Birotron in '78?


To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:
Mellotronists-unsubscribe@yahoogroups.com



Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to the Yahoo! Terms of Service.

Re: [Mellotronists] YES & Rick

2002-05-10 by fdoddy@aol.com

In a message dated 05/09/2002 8:40:59 PM Eastern Daylight Time, chris.dale@... writes:


According to an interview in Keyboard magazine, producer Jonathan Elias tried to goad Wakeman to play the part, and when Wakeman refused, decided to play it himself.


FYI I work for Jonathan Elias. Any tron on Union are samples and many of Wakeman's parts were scrapped and played by session dudes.

Fritz

Re: [Mellotronists] YES & Rick

2002-05-10 by ferrograph@aol.com

(andy t)
<< One thing I do credit Yes with doing is keeping the mellotron flame alive

for more than a decade. >>

that would be rick, for his work with the band..... and his incendiary 
retirement of the thing afterwards. :-) 

bit of a bad gambler when it came to keyboards, after that; he started so 
brightly, designing the front of the p5 by nicking the front of a minimoog 
and restyling it after bang&olufsen, but then came the birotron, the elcaset 
of keyboards, and then an endorsement or somesuch with cheetah.... 

does moraz still own a machine? what does he do for one since mark glinsky 
left florida? I tried to acquire the moraz-rack once, but I believe it's 
still in germany somewhere.

"yes album" has no 'tron, affirming andy's contention that squire's rick, 
rather than rick wakeman, has provided the band's history with an always 
obvious consistent element, changing the history of rock bass in the process.
 
bruford attributes his development of a very rimmy snare style to having to 
compete with the other rick in the band too; I bought ABWH thinking that the 
four of them ought to be able to make a decent fist of it, especially with 
bruford's work away from the band being pretty strong, but the lack of squire 
ultimately costs the album the few "oh well, it was the 80s" points it might 
have in my house. 
meanwhile a badly recorded bbc sessions set I got on double cd, of "yes" 
album (not "yes album") songs and earlier, stayed in the walkman for weeks. 
but then I am a bassist.  these songs already demonstrate the band's interest 
in strings, though, and "space oddity" was everywhere by then, so making a 
move on rick was obvious.

now, about this new standard set. does it have a name yet?

duncan/1974 rickenbacker 4001s, 1996 rickenbacker 4003/5 and a mellotron. and 
some biros.

Re: [Mellotronists] YES & Rick

2002-05-10 by kenmerb@aol.com

In a message dated 5/9/02 9:09:22 PM Eastern Daylight Time, 
ferrograph@... writes:


> does moraz still own a machine? what does he do for one since mark glinsky 
> left florida? I tried to acquire the moraz-rack once, but I believe it's 
> still in germany somewhere.

Last year I visited the studio in Orlando where Moraz is set up.  The studio 
owner gave me the full tour, and I got to check out Moraz's entire setup - 
unfortunately,  he was in Switzerland at the time.  Not a Mellotron in sight. 
 He had a Kurzweil 2500 XS workstation with a CDROM for loading samples.  If 
he uses Mellotron sounds these days, they are samples.  He had some other 
nice midi keyboards there, I can't remember which makes or models.  I took 
some photos, I'll post them to my web site if I can find them.  BTW, the 
studio owner had just about every vintage keyboard ever made there ( it's 
actually a synth museum too ), and he was dying to get his hands on a 
Mellotron.  I think that's why he was so nice to me  - he shot the whole day 
showing me around the place.

Ken M.

Move to quarantaine

This moves the raw source file on disk only. The archive index is not changed automatically, so you still need to run a manual refresh afterward.