Mellotronists group photo

Yahoo Groups archive

Mellotronists

Index last updated: 2026-03-31 23:14 UTC

Thread

Genesis SACDs 1976 - 1982

Genesis SACDs 1976 - 1982

2007-04-03 by kinchmusic@aol.com

Anyone here got the remixed Genesis SACDs yet? All digitally remixed into 5.1 and sounding wonderful and squeaky clean, I got mine yesterday. I would have thought that if you heard them, they might well provoke some discussion here.
IMHO they do sound wonderful for their age, though I would urge you not to get rid of your original CD copies if you have them, as apparently the new versions will be the only ones you'll be able to buy new from now on. (Though thankfully there'll always be Ebay}
The reason I'll be keeping my original remasters is that in general I still prefer the overall sound of these. Why, I don't know except to say that the tron seems to be better treated way back when. On the new versions, it sounds a bit weedy in places and mixed well back.
Case in point, Entangled. One of my all time favourite Tron moments ever, just doesn't happen in the same way as it does on the original. The choir just isn't as big as it should have been. Also Mad man moon also on ATOTT. The lovely strings of the original just don't sound as sweet. Don't get me wrong, the news isn't all bad by any means. Elsewhere it all sounds rather lovely. Nick Davis has done a great job overall. It's said that Tony Banks had a huge influence on the mix, and we all know what he thinks of the machine! Where was Steve Hackett when you needed him?
Still, go and buy. The experience of listening to these in surround is a joy.
Not better, just different.
Andy K

Re: [Mellotronists] Genesis SACDs 1976 - 1982

2007-04-04 by Jim Anderson

You might also be interested in a recent recording posted on Wolfgang's Vault, recorded Jan. 1975 at The Shrine in L.A.:

From what I've heard it's the same show as is on the boxed set but is not remixed & overdubbed like the one on the box set. I was going to stream/record it but then I thought: how many versions of The Lamb do I need?? I feel similarly about the SACDs.... I've already bought some of these albums two or three times!
JimA

On Apr 3, 2007, at 10:20 AM, kinchmusic@... wrote:

Show quoted textHide quoted text
Anyone here got the remixed Genesis SACDs yet? All digitally remixed into 5.1 and sounding wonderful and squeaky clean, I got mine yesterday. I would have thought that if you heard them, they might well provoke some discussion here.
IMHO they do sound wonderful for their age, though I would urge you not to get rid of your original CD copies if you have them, as apparently the new versions will be the only ones you'll be able to buy new from now on. (Though thankfully there'll always be Ebay}
The reason I'll be keeping my original remasters is that in general I still prefer the overall sound of these. Why, I don't know except to say that the tron seems to be better treated way back when. On the new versions, it sounds a bit weedy in places and mixed well back.
Case in point, Entangled. One of my all time favourite Tron moments ever, just doesn't happen in the same way as it does on the original. The choir just isn't as big as it should have been. Also Mad man moon also on ATOTT. The lovely strings of the original just don't sound as sweet. Don't get me wrong, the news isn't all bad by any means. Elsewhere it all sounds rather lovely. Nick Davis has done a great job overall. It's said that Tony Banks had a huge influence on the mix, and we all know what he thinks of the machine! Where was Steve Hackett when you needed him?
Still, go and buy. The experience of listening to these in surround is a joy.
Not better, just different.
Andy K