Archive of the former Yahoo!Groups mailing list: Mellotronists

previous by date index next by date
previous in topic topic list next in topic

Subject: RE: Graeme/Moodies (was RE: [Mellotronists] Re: Frank Stickle's turn)

From: "Pomeroy Ranch" <punchbowl4@...>
Date: 2006-09-03

-----OriginalMessage-----
Con:

    Graham'sdrumming (although he did appear to spend some time in

     the woodshed circa "LDV"

Actually, Graeme is quite a good andinnovative drummer – unlike boring metronomes like Charlie Watts. Listenalso to the two Gurvitz albums – the first oneincluding a certain red-haired wildman pitching in onthe skins.

 

One has to remember too that the Moodies have always been a rock band with an edge (oops!pun) – not just Montovani on acid – I remember my Led-Zep-Bonzo-lovin (read: “loud” and“raucous”) drummer at a Moodies concertresponding to an uninitiated fellow in a nearby seat who asked if this wasgoing to be a mellow concert by saying: “No, no – they rock!”

 

I think the key to the difference you hearon record and live is the inimitable Tony Clarke. Pipand Visconti were quite different….listen tothe “classic eighth” Moodies album (BlueJays) with Tony producing – excellent work again – and even theGodley/Creme production of “Blue Guitar”,while trying hard to imitate Tony, misses it. Without Tony, things justaren’t the same in the studio: 4-track or 24 – and live you get tohear the raw product – and it’s still a helluvalot of fun….

 

Cheers!

Vance (waiting for the fur to fly re: anyone of the following – my taste, Adrian Gurvitz,Ginger Baker, Paul Gurvitz, Montovani, mydrummer…..)