Archive of the former Yahoo!Groups mailing list: Mellotronists

previous by date index next by date
previous in topic topic list next in topic

Subject: Re: [Mellotronists] OFF TOPIC (Mellotronic content restored)

From: "jonesalley" <jonesalley@...>
Date: 2004-11-28

Thanks to both Andys for preserving what sanity I have.  The Elton John/Wakeman reference really threw me as a seminal Wakeman fan.  The only Mellotron I can recall on Elton John's material through about 1979 was on "Grey Seal" and if I recall correctly, Elton is credited on the liner notes as the Mellotronist.  Although I haven't heard it in years, my memory of the orchestrations in question contradicted the idea that they were keyboard parts, so I'm really glad somebody said that before I had to ask the list!  Also noted, the incorrect spelling of Harry "Chamberlain" in the article.
 

Not to mention a bizarre comment re.Mellotron use on an Elton John album that has nothing of the sort. Good, informed article otherwise, on an excellent open-source resource.
 
Andy T.
 
 
Madman Accross the Water..."where all of the orchestral parts were provided by a studio Mellotron played by Rick Wakeman." They must be joking! Paul Buckmaster would be very much offended by that! I know the tron is good but not that good! I might be wrong but I don't think RW ever played on any of EJ's albums. I know that on Goodbye Yellow Brick Road, any tron that appeared there was played by EJ himself.
Andy K