Yahoo Groups archive

Homebrew_PCBs

Index last updated: 2026-03-31 13:47 UTC

Thread

Looking for opinions on PCB methods....

Looking for opinions on PCB methods....

2003-11-24 by kg4wfx

Hi all,

I appologize for the rather vague subject line, but I'm having a
little trouble.

First off, want to say hi to the list, Although I have done some PCB
etching and such, I still consider myself a very newbie.

Here is my problem - I'm looking to decide on a path to follow for
doing my pcb's at home. I really only expect to do single and dual
layer boards.

My problem is methodology.

I've done a little photo resist, some ink resist, etc., but I'm at a
crossroads now.

I'm either going to follow the path of photoresist and etch, and buy
or build a UV exposure box. Or I am going to go the path of getting
an inexpensive or homebuilt CNC router to cut out my PCB traces.

I've talked with one person that happens to be on the list and he
prefers the etching methods.

But I really am looking for opinions - I don't want to start a war,
which I know a post like this can do, so if you prefer to respond to
me in private, that's fine.

My personal thoughts, the reason why I am fence hedging right now
is...

Etching - chemicals hazardus with disposal rules, extra time taken
to print transparency, expose the board, develop the board, then
etch the board. Not sure where to get a good supply of the
photoresist and developer, negative or positive. Been using pre-
sensitized boards, but would rather self-sensitize the boards as
needed.

Routing - Seems quicker, generates a bit of a mess, can't do as
dense traces which limits use of surface mount chips, or higher
density TH chips. More difficult to align for dual sided boards.
significantly more expensive to enter into, but equipment could be
used for other things. Not sure where to find quality bits for
routing PCB's (the angular tip ones)

The other thing I'm confused about is the solder mask (I think
that's what it's called) - the green layer commonly found on
production PCB's -is it possible to find this stuff and how
difficult is it to apply?

I really hate to ask so many questions in one email, but I've been
reading thru the files on this site, and the links provided in the
links section, as well as the past several pages of posts, and I'm
still unsure of where/how to proceed.

-Tony

Re: Looking for opinions on PCB methods....

2003-11-25 by Dave Mucha

> Routing - Seems quicker, generates a bit of a mess, can't do as
> dense traces which limits use of surface mount chips, or higher
> density TH chips. More difficult to align for dual sided boards.
> significantly more expensive to enter into, but equipment could be
> used for other things. Not sure where to find quality bits for
> routing PCB's (the angular tip ones)

Don't forget the dust is copper and fiberglass. unless you remove it
as the source, it will chew up your machine.


As far as bits, go, Harbor Freight often has 10 bits for 10 bux or 50
bits for 25 bux. there are others around. Most often, these are
really high quality bits that are ground out of tolerance.




>
> The other thing I'm confused about is the solder mask (I think
> that's what it's called) - the green layer commonly found on
> production PCB's -is it possible to find this stuff and how
> difficult is it to apply?


I wonder how to get the stuff everywhere but on the pads !

This is a thread I'd like to see get discussed.

Dave

Re: Looking for opinions on PCB methods....

2003-11-25 by kg4wfx

>
> >
> > The other thing I'm confused about is the solder mask (I think
> > that's what it's called) - the green layer commonly found on
> > production PCB's -is it possible to find this stuff and how
> > difficult is it to apply?
>
>
> I wonder how to get the stuff everywhere but on the pads !
>
> This is a thread I'd like to see get discussed.
>

This is an interesting one - I have found only one solution so far,
but I'm not sure how I feel about it yet.

There is a GC product called Red Insulating Varnish - this varnish
can be thinned with another GC product (which I can't remember the
name of off hand) - but from a vendor that I had purchased from in
the past, they had said that it has been done where you make a print
of the solder mask, and develop a printing screen for it, with the
thinner, thin the varnish to a point where it can be used in the
printing screen like a normal ink and viola (sp?) instant
soldermask/insulation layer.

Keep in mind I have NOT tried this yet, but I do plan to at some
point when I have my screen printer that I anticipate getting for
christmas.

Also, it's a red coloring, so it won't look normal ;)

-Tony

Re: Looking for opinions on PCB methods....

2003-11-25 by wheedal99

There's a Japanese site that I saw (didn't bookmark) that the guy
just put some tiny stickers to mask off individual pads. The solder
mask was also a Japanese labled product and came in a spray can.
Peeled the stickers off after the laquer setup. It looked pretty
good when he was done, but man that's pretty maticulous.

Found it!
http://www.interq.or.jp/japan/se-inoue/e_pwbm.htm

--- In Homebrew_PCBs@yahoogroups.com, "Dave Mucha"> > The other thing
I'm confused about is the solder mask (I think
> > that's what it's called) - the green layer commonly found on
> > production PCB's -is it possible to find this stuff and how
> > difficult is it to apply?
>
>
> I wonder how to get the stuff everywhere but on the pads !

Re: masking and pads.

2003-11-25 by Dave Mucha

--- In Homebrew_PCBs@yahoogroups.com, "kg4wfx" <tony@e...> wrote:
> >
> > >
> > > The other thing I'm confused about is the solder mask (I think
> > > that's what it's called) - the green layer commonly found on
> > > production PCB's -is it possible to find this stuff and how
> > > difficult is it to apply?
> >
> >
> > I wonder how to get the stuff everywhere but on the pads !
> >
> > This is a thread I'd like to see get discussed.
> >
>
> This is an interesting one - I have found only one solution so far,
> but I'm not sure how I feel about it yet.
>
> There is a GC product called Red Insulating Varnish - this varnish
> can be thinned with another GC product (which I can't remember the
> name of off hand) - but from a vendor that I had purchased from in
> the past, they had said that it has been done where you make a
print
> of the solder mask, and develop a printing screen for it, with the
> thinner, thin the varnish to a point where it can be used in the
> printing screen like a normal ink and viola (sp?) instant
> soldermask/insulation layer.
>
> Keep in mind I have NOT tried this yet, but I do plan to at some
> point when I have my screen printer that I anticipate getting for
> christmas.
>
> Also, it's a red coloring, so it won't look normal ;)
>
> -Tony


OK, There are work arounds, but what do the board houses do ?

I was thinking a little brush on the drill so if you maksed first,
the brush could scrape the mask off, but then that would have to be
before thru-holes are plated.....

I would think the mask it last ?

Dave

Re: Looking for opinions on PCB methods....

2003-11-28 by Ben H. Lanmon

I use the positive method using MG Chemicals borads, etch with
Ferric Chloride. I like this best of any that I have tried. Yes it
is a lot of stuff to have set up, you really need a room or rooms
just for this if you make PCB's very offen. Make the Positive with
Transparency film with a ink jet printer and using Ivex Winboard
software.

Ben