Yahoo Groups archive

Homebrew PCBs

Index last updated: 2026-04-28 23:05 UTC

Message

Re: New Scematic capture & PCB software

2006-02-14 by rmustakos

>   While I don't know the orginal poster from a the next guy on the 
> street, I do share Mike's skepticism on the "I've been dealing 
> with the limitations of eagle for making pcbs for a few years
> now, and finally hit a problem I could not resolve."  It is
> likely to boil down to one of three options:
> 
> 1.  The 'problem' is real but actually tiny, and the OP's idea of an 
> 'unresolvable' problem takes 5 minutes to figure out with Google.
> 2.  The 'problem' is imaginary, totally manufactured to stump the 
> OP's agenda, paid or not.
> 3.  The near zero % chance of something that doesn't fall into the
> two above options.
> 
Hi Alan, nice to meet you, I'm Richard, the OP. 
The problem falls into section 3.  I'm making a PCI-104 board with a
lot of high count surface mount parts, and I need at least 4 layers,
and probably 6.
> 
>   It's one of the least limited programs I've ever used.  A bit 
> obtuse on how to do some things, but that's what Google is for.
> And at least when you get past your own 'teething' of how to use
> it, it's potential is already largely there.  Not some far off
> thing you want that may never even be programmed in..
> 
I've been happily bitching at eagle since sometime in 02, and I agree
with your assessment: it's a very capable program.  But the hard
limits on size and number of layers are hard limits.  I did RTFM, and
I am posting about kicad because of my own agenda, which is to help
other hobbiests overcome problems that have beat me up.
Kicad is free ware, I'm not a developer, I am not a seller, I am not
associated with it in any manner other than being a user, though I am
considering getting involved in the development, if I can ever get the
components to all work together in VS2005.
Thanks
Richard
P.S.  I do believe in a healthy dose of scepticism, and agree with
your list of 3 possible problems, I just always tend to be about 3
sigma, so I get to fall in section 3 most of the time.

Attachments

Move to quarantaine

This moves the raw source file on disk only. The archive index is not changed automatically, so you still need to run a manual refresh afterward.