ahhh....skate bearings....of course! <g> Sorry 'bout that...I should've figured that one out myself. Put it down to late-night fatigue. Aren't ABEC-9 bearings an ultra-tight machine-tool grade? What the heck are they doing in -rollerskates- ?? I'd think they'd be $50 to $100 bearings! I guess if you're only drilling a few holes, limiting the feedrate is OK. I have had to drill boards with 600+ holes; and have no desire to -slow- the machine! <grin> I'm currently running my Techno table at 400ipm slew, and around 400,000 steps/sec/sec accelerations, so the drill-down time has now become the larger portion of the overall job-time. And with 60krpm instead of 25-30k, I could -double- my trace-cutting speed...which would be really sweet! Don't know about you guys, but whenever I'm waiting for a board to finish isolation, I'm alway chomping at the bit wanting it to be DONE, so I can build it and see how it works! <g> I can't spend $3000 for a spindle, but I've worn out so many crappy Dremels over the past 15 yrs, that I've easily burnt up $300-400 so far. I'd gladly spend, say, $300, for a nice little 50-60krpm unit with decent runout and not-outrageous noise. If one were available. Buy one decent spindle, and be done with the problem forever. But the market is probably too small for anyone to make such a thing; especially if nobody is willing to spend more than $39. Air: I've always kept my compressor outside under a little 'shelter', for lack of a better word. Also, I chose a unit with a 60-gal tank...it hardly runs at all. So the worry about compressor-noise hasn't been an issue for me. I would think that a purpose-built PCB spindle would consume far less air than those cheap die-grinders. I know that the 200krpm dental handpieces use hardly any air at all. The airlines feeding them are only about .100" ID ! Air-consumption is directly proportional to both precision and power-output; and PCB drilling/isolation isn't a high HP job. It would seem that 50-100W would be plenty. The Dremel is...about 125W -input- power, if I recall right. Of course, it's such an inefficient motor that it's -output- power is probably only 75-100W, and that's at full load. What it actually produces during drilling might only be a fraction of that...25-50W of mechanical power maybe? A well-made 50-100W air-motor spindle might be pretty reasonable on consumption. Die-grinders are noisy because they run open exhaust; right there in your face. But if the exhaust is plumbed away, and if the tool is made well, an air motor can be pretty quiet. I once worked on some air-powered factory-automation equipment that used plumbed exhaust; and was pleasantly surprised at how easy it was to stand right next to it while discussing it in normal tones. Heck, it's not like these cheap electric tools are very quiet themselves... <g> Appreciate everyone's thoughts and viewpoints on this. It's very interesting. The spindle is such a key portion of the setup. -- ============================ Please do NOT add or "subscribe" me to any lists or databases.
Message
Re: What spindles are in use?
2006-01-19 by Richard
Attachments
- No local attachments were found for this message.