Yahoo Groups archive

Digital BW, The Print

Index last updated: 2026-04-28 22:56 UTC

Message

smooth gradient on matte problem

2006-01-07 by Dennis Dowling

Hi,
	I hear a lot of people are printing on matte papers. I have a new epson r2400 but haven't been able to get a good result on matte. Mainly, I have smooth gradient black to gray sky that prints nice and smooth on glossy and semi-gloss paper. But, on matte it comes out as a very abrupt gradient - a big swath of black next to a big swath of gray. Also, there is a lot less detail in the shadows on matte. Notice the tower in top-right that is clearly distinct on glossy but not matte. 

Here's a link to a scan of a test print clipping. I know the scan doesn't recreate the prints well, but the difference is even more obvious looking at the actual prints.

http://bmxweb.com/printtest.jpg

This is just a small test print but I had the same result at full size.
epson r2400 on epson premium glossy (PK ink) and epson enhanced matte (MK ink)
Best Photo, Advanced BW default settings
using epson's printer/paper specific profiles
letting photoshop determine colors with rel.colorimetric & blk.pt.comp.

	I understand that black is less dense/dark on matte paper and I don't mind that. I tried shifting ink color density and max optical density. But, I'm just wondering if it's normal/accepted that smooth gradients look better on glossy paper than on matte. Or, is there a way to get a smooth gradient transition on matte paper? Should I keep experimenting with settings or do I just need better matte paper, or different inks?

thanks, - Den.

Attachments

Move to quarantaine

This moves the raw source file on disk only. The archive index is not changed automatically, so you still need to run a manual refresh afterward.