Yahoo Groups archive

Digital BW, The Print

Index last updated: 2026-04-28 22:56 UTC

Message

RE: [Digital BW] D60 info request

2002-05-23 by Austin Franklin

Hi Steadman,

I know that the Canon D30 and D60 use a CMOS imaging sensor, not a CCD, but
that's not relevant to any of the comments I made.  Everything I said is
applicable to either.

I typically say "CCD" rather than "CMOS chip" etc., as most people know that
a CCD refers to the imaging sensor.  In most cases, and certainly in this
case, the discussion applies to both types of imaging sensors.  "CMOS chip"
does not necessarily refer to an imaging sensor, as CMOS is simply an IC
manufacturing process, and many other "chips" are CMOS (probably most in the
camera in fact), but CCD is pretty much universally referring to an imaging
sensor.  Perhaps I'll simply say "imaging sensor" next time for amorphous
accuracy ;-)

Austin


> -----Original Message-----
> From: Steadman Uhlich [mailto:steadmanuhlich@...]
> Sent: Thursday, May 23, 2002 8:47 AM
> To: DigitalBlackandWhiteThePrint@yahoogroups.com
> Subject: Re: [Digital BW] D60 info request
>
>
> Austin,
>
> The D30 and D60 use a CMOS chip and not a CCD.
>
> Steadman
>
>   ----- Original Message -----
>   From: Austin Franklin
>   To: DigitalBlackandWhiteThePrint@yahoogroups.com
>   Sent: Wednesday, May 22, 2002 10:08 PM
>   Subject: RE: [Digital BW] D60 info request
>
>
>
>   Hi Jerry,
>
>   > Hi Austin,
>   >
>   > > >   Quality for 13x19 inch prints equals
>   > > >   film with the D60.
>   > >
>   > > Equals WHAT film?  Not ALL film, that's for sure.
>   >
>   > Certainly NOT!
>   >
>   > Austin, you obviously see quality in scans I don't see. My
> D30 gives me
>   > extremely sharp,
>
>   Of course.  Line art images are extremely sharp too, but they
> have no detail
>   or tonality ;-)  To me, sharpness isn't an indication of "good" or
>   "quality".  If there were tones in the original image that
> aren't duplicated
>   in the recorded image, information has been lost...though the
> image may be
>   very sharp.
>
>   > detailed closeups. It equals provia 100, or supra 100,
>   > or Reala 100 etc. I've made the side by side tests.
>
>   What size prints?  For a 4x6, no doubt, and for even some 8x10,
> but for a 13
>   x 19, well, been there, done that...have some on my photo
> board.  Not even
>   close.
>
>   > Believe me when I tell you the
>   > 13x19 inch print is great.
>
>   It depends on what you mean by "great".  It WILL be sharp, but
> it WILL not
>   contain the same detail as a print made from film.  It
> physically can not,
>   and really doesn't.  I've been doing this (digital imaging) for
> a long time,
>   and I have a number of digital cameras.  I know the results.
> The D-30 isn't
>   magic.
>
>   > I just don't care what the technical data
>   > says. I have the prints, and I know what I see.
>
>   Same here.
>
>   > I know that the D60 will
>   > be much better than the D30, and I'm completely satisfied
> with the D30,
>   > for closeups. I'm quite sure the D60 will give me the results
> I need in
>   > landscape photography.
>
>   If you believe it works for you, that's good!  I am not saying
> it doesn't
>   work for you, as only YOU know that.  But, I'm saying your
> conclusions as to
>   "quality" aren't the same as mine.
>
>   > Remember, I'm only talking about 13x19 prints.
>
>   Me too ;-)
>
>   > When you rez the D30 up to 240 DPI for the 13x19 inch prints, I really
>   > can't see any loss in quality. You say there is, in detail,
> that it just
>   > can't be as good.
>
>   Well I CAN see the loss in "quality", as well as many other
> people can.  If
>   sharpness is your primary indication of "quality", then you're
> going to have
>   a different conclusion than someone who has some other property as their
>   primary indication of quality.  "rezzing up" an image does NOT provide
>   detail that simply is not there in the first place in the
> recorded image.
>
>   > I am happy with the camera, and I guess this is all that
> matters to me.
>
>   Bingo!  And that's what matters to you.
>
>   > No, I never EVER said in all circumstances. I'm talking
> closeups, ( Cat
>   > portraits), and Extremely sharp lenses here.
>
>   There's actually something "funny" about that.  Sharp lenses
> mean nothing on
>   this camera.  The issue is there is a "low pass" filter (some call it
>   "anti-aliasing" filter) between the lense and the CCD.  Why this is
>   important to understand is this filter actually "dumbs down"
> the lense so
>   the MTF of the lense matches the CCD pitch.  The sharpness of
> the lense, on
>   that camera, really doesn't matter...you'd probably get equally
> as good a
>   result with a Sigma or Tamaron etc. lense, than a high end
> piece of glass,
>   as far as "sharpness" goes that is.
>
>   > There is a big difference
>   > between Top grade glass and average lenses, and it really shows
>   > up in digital.
>
>   Actually, that's is not true, as I stated above.  Most of the
> web sites that
>   talk about this stuff acknowledge this readily.  Even DPReview
> says that the
>   D-60 is probably the first digital camera (as far as the 35mm-esque
>   varieties) that the lense might actually matter ;-)
>
>   Regards,
>
>   Austin
>
>
>         Yahoo! Groups Sponsor
>               ADVERTISEMENT
>
>
>

Attachments

Move to quarantaine

This moves the raw source file on disk only. The archive index is not changed automatically, so you still need to run a manual refresh afterward.