My only comment here is that I always sharpen after, not before resizing.
Richard
I started with the first Genuine Fractals and have used every permutation since — up to and including the latest "Perfect Resize." I have always had satisfactory results. The latest versions give you some options that are best done in Photoshop (IMHO), sharpening being one of those.
Joe
On 10/22/2014 21:36, Paul Roark roark.paul@... [DigitalBlackandWhiteThePrint] wrote:
The only testing I've done on up-sizing relates to minimizing the losses where there are geometric alterations in the file, like in stitching. In those cases a "smart" up-res (old Genuine Fractals/Perfect Resize or -- better -- PS CC in auto mode) of 200% does seem to preserve details. See http://www.paulroark.com/BW-Info/Perfect-Resize-comparison.jpg
Paul
On Wed, Oct 22, 2014 at 3:40 PM, Myron Gochnauer goch@... [DigitalBlackandWhiteThePrint] <DigitalBlackandWhiteThePrint@yahoogroups.com> wrote:
Is there any received wisdom on when resizing of an image should be done during processing?
>From experience, but not careful testing, I do any upsizing in Photoshop as early as possible in my processing, but after I have performed any necessary noise reduction.
My untested thinking is that upsizing before noise reduction might make noise reduction less reliable, since upsizing always involves *some* degree of guessing and so has some reasonable likelihood of producing random noise artifacts. (I use noise reduction plugins that rely on analyzing the image, or a representatively similar image. The more uniform and predictable the noise is, the better they seem to work.)
Have any of you done careful tests to solve this problem? If not, does my approach seem sensible?
Every time I decide I should test this, I run into complications in the nature of “well, it depends. . .”. And, of course, it usually doesn’t make any visible difference at all when I finally just get it up on the wall. :-)
Myron
-- Joe Dempsey 870.550.0191 http://www.joedempseyphoto.com/ http://www.corndancer.com/joephoto/photohome.html http://weeklygrist.wordpress.com/
