previous by date | index | next by date |
previous in topic | topic list | next in topic |
>
> Couple of thoughts...
>
> Don is still in this business and still sells 292
> Lopass Gates (quad version). This is not my design,
> even with the mods. I added something to Peter to
> something from Paul to make a "compilation" PCB of
> sorts.
>
> Honestly, I never thought the project would get the
> desire that people have shown due to the many other
> versions on the market. My boards are sold for
> extremely cheap compared to others out there so maybe
> that had something to do with it. The project was
> posted on Electro Music for months before a 2-week
> order period began. I regret to have missed people,
> but keep in mind my request of Don involved a single
> run and not one that would compete with Euro format
> directly out of respect for Peter Grenader, Doepfer,
> Wiard, etc
>
> If Don says go for it I'll advertise here, on AH and
> on synth_diy this time and not on Electro-Music to try
> and hit others that missed the limited first run. In
> the end, I am not in this as a business. I made boards
> that filled my immediate need and shared with others.
> One does not have any idea how much time it takes to
> make boards, take orders, and ship them around the
> world until you try it... that is the foundation for
> any hesitation to really do this, and part of why I
> hope to partner with Bridechamber for future
> distribution along with his convenient offering of
> MOTM-format panels since no one has previously made a
> LPG in that format. All my best,
>
> Thomas
> --- David Vandenberg <dragonslair@...> wrote:
>
> > Am I missing something here?
> > This is a second run of boards, did you get
> > permission from Don for
> > the first run? if so, why would you need permission
> > for a second run
> > of the same board?
> > On another note, the basic idea and design was
> > Don's, you have
> > modified the design and added other aspects to the
> > circuit, so it is
> > no longer his design, but yours. 90% of the designs
> > in DIY (and in
> > production synth modules) are based on something
> > else, whether it is
> > someone else's circuit, a modification of the app
> > notes for the IC, or
> > a circuit out of the old Electronotes, it doesn't
> > matter, if you make
> > any changes to it, it is now your design, most of my
> > designs are based
> > around the chip manufacturers app notes, or a
> > circuit I found in
> > Electronotes, so according to your logic I should be
> > asking the chip
> > manufacturers for their permission before I get any
> > boards done up, or
> > I should spend years trying to track down the guy
> > who submitted the
> > circuit to Electronotes 30 years ago, sometimes this
> > "Intellectual
> > Property" can be pushed a bit to far.
> > If you want to make a direct clone of a specific
> > module
> > (panels,circuit,pcb) then yes, you should get the
> > original designers
> > permission, otherwise I see no reason for it.
> >
> > My 2 cents worth,
> > Dave
> >
> >
>
>
> Thomas White
> Natural Rhythm
> www.naturalrhythmmusic.com
>