Yes it was John Hawken, Actually the song was part of the Ill-faded
NOW project that Keith was trying to get together. When he died Jim
was roped into taking the group over. While Jim does play drums on
NOW demos he had no interest in being involved in that project at
all. It was not until Keith died and Jane and the band convinced Jim
to take over.
You might be interested to know that Jim reformed Renaissance and
issued a new Cd. Jane is now somewhat retired from the business but
on occasion if Jim asks she will sing. She suffers severe stage
fright. The new Yardbirds cd features a song called Mystery of Being
which is also found on the Renaissance-Illusion cd Through the fire.
As you may know John Hawken lives in USA, so the only one left who is
missing is John Knightsbridge who is reported to be living somewhere
in the USA.
The reason for the confusion on who recorded on that track was the
fact it was the last formal session Keith Relf ever did and their is
alot of emotion connected to those Keith Relf "NOW" sessions. In my
personal conversation with Jim he indicated he only has played the
piano. One recent bit of informatoin that was brought to my attention
by Jim was that he in fact did demos of the songs that were done by
Renaissance featuring Annie. I don't know if there is mellotron on
them or not.
Rick
--- In Mellotronists@yahoogroups.com, "aidan60uk" <aidan@a...> wrote:
> Back in February we were trying to figure out who played the
> Mellotron on "All the Falling Angels". Was it John Hawken or not?
I
> have just been reliably informed that, yes, it was the maestro John
> Hawken. The track appears on the Illusion album "Enchanted Caress"
> but was actually performed by Keith Relf's NoW. (The history of
> Renaissance/Illusion etc., is rather complicated.) Illusion's
> earlier album "Out of the Mist" is one of my all-time favourites
and
> there is Mellotron on several tracks. People who like Renaissance
> and 1970s BJH should enjoy it. Aidan