[sdiy] A question of CV ins
David G Dixon
dixon at mail.ubc.ca
Sun Jan 22 22:17:30 CET 2012
> Why not one?
> Because then you need mixer modules instead.
>
> It moves the user interaction from the actual module, adding
> some confusion, and it rarely even saves panel components.
> It's a matter of taste I guess, but I personally think that
> this need of mixer modules (or, even worse, attenuator
> modules) is an extremely bad UI design.
> :-)
>
> (N.B.: This applies also to audio inputs... for instance,
> designing a VCF with a single audio input is a huge mistake
> considering how often a user would want to sum 2 or 3 signals there.)
I agree wholeheartedly. My filters always have 3-input mixers on every
channel, and I use them a lot. For CV inputs, I think you really need to
figure out how you use your modules, and customize them accordingly. I
would personally never require 5 CV inputs for VCO pitch, as Harry suggests,
but peoples' needs differ. If you overdo it, then you end up taking a lot
of panel real estate for stuff you will never use. If you underdo it, then
you will always kick yourself every time you patch that module. The nice
thing about DIY is that you can try stuff out, and if you want to make
changes, just make them, or do it differently on the next build.
More information about the Synth-diy
mailing list