[sdiy] MPF102 sub
Ian Fritz
ijfritz at comcast.net
Thu Sep 22 22:24:17 CEST 2011
In days of old the 2n3819 was used as a near equivalent to the MPF102. It
is still manufactured (Central Semi) and is available from Mouser.
Other FETs available from Mouser are:
J105, J107, J109, J111, J112, J113, J310
BF256
2n4392, 2n4393
2n4416
2n5460
2n5484, 2n5485, 2n5486.
Things to remember: Just because a certain substitution can be made in one
project doesn't mean it can be made in all projects. When you purchase a
bunch you usually get pinchoff voltages near the "typical" value, which may
be much smaller than the max value. If you need a low pinchoff you can
always hope that works, but in general you should measure the pinchoff
voltage to be sure. Do not substitute a MOSFET unless you know what you
are doing. Most n-channel types are enhancement-mode devices, meaning that
the bias requirements are different. Additionally, nearly all have
protection diodes, which means they cannot switch bipolar signals. Plus,
they have large input capacitance unless you track down the few devices
that are suitable for low-power switching. This capacitance can put huge
switching transients on the signal, so that for discharging a VCO cap the
output is very messy.
I've pretty much decided that for future designs I'm going to use the IC
switches (dg211, etc.) Even though they are expensive, there are no
worries about pinchoff voltage variations, and I doubt they are going to
vanish anytime soon.
Ian
More information about the Synth-diy
mailing list