[sdiy] MIDI isn't musical : Flame bait? Hells, yeah!

[Chris Randall]

> Umm ... don't most people record from a keyboard controller (which makes
no
> sound) and play back to different synths? My statement was in response to
> the previous post which stated that it wouldn't make sense to instrument a
> Hammond with sensors and actuators just to be able to record and play back
> via MIDI. It sounds like you didn't read the posts and are taking my
> comment out of context.

Okay. I give up. I wrote the post you were responding to. If you're not
going to provide a context for your argument, you can't say that I took your
statement out of context. This is turning in to an Analog Heaven debate.

My main controller _is_ a K2600, and it's not that expensive. It is
remarkably average-priced, compared to the other normal tools that a
professional musician uses. It is comperable in price to a Triton or a
usable MOTM system, and about the same as any other flagship synth was when
it came out (e.g. Prophet 5, DX 7, 2600, or your precious VL-1.)

In any case, I'm done with this. If you want to be right, you can be right.
Have fun.

-Chris Randall